Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

157 F.2d 738

Docket No. 13230.

Downing v. United States

Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided Oct. 4, 1946.

Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1946-10-04

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““Prior to Dunn v. United States, 284 U.S. 390 , 52 S.Ct. 189 , 76 L.Ed. 356 ; 80 A.L.R. 161 , there had been a conflict in the federal courts on whether an inconsistent verdict on the seperate counts of an indictment could support a criminal sentence. The Dunn case settled the .question, however, when the Supreme Court refused to reverse a conviction for inconsistency in verdict on the separate counts of an indictment, involving the same evidence, and said, 284 U.S. at page 393, 52 S.Ct. at page 190: ‘Consistency in the verdiet is not necessary. Each count in an indictment is regarded as if it was a separate indictment. * * * If separate indictments had been presented against the defendant for possession (of intoxicating liquor) and for maintenance of a nuisance, and had been separately tried, the *771 same evidence being offered in support of each, an acquittal on one could not be pleaded as res judicata of the other. Where the offenses are separately charged in the counts of a single indictment the same rule must hold.’ ””

quoted by 1 later decision, including Anderson v. United States

Relies on Dunn v. United States · Pilgreen v. United States

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1946-10-04

How this case has been cited

Cited by 14 later decisions — most recently April 1971

13 federal appellate ·

501946195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Gordon C. Peterson, of Columbia Heights, Minn., for appellant.

¶2Clifford F. Hansen, Asst. U. S. Atty., of St. Paul, Minn. (Victor E. Anderson, U. S. Atty., of St. Paul, Minn., on the brief), for appellee.

¶3Before SANBORN, THOMAS, and JOHNSEN, Circuit Judges.

¶4JOHNSEN, Circuit Judge.

¶5Appellant was convicted by a jury on a count in an information charging him with *739unlawfully having obtained the removal of a tenant from a housing accommodation in the Minneapolis-St. Paul Defense Rental Area, in violation of “Rent Regulation for Housing,”1 ******8 Fed.Reg. 14663, under the Emergency Price Control Act of 1942, as amended, 50 U.S.C.A.Appendix, §§ 901-946, by falsely stating in the notice to quit that “the landlord seeks to recover possession, in good faith, for the immediate purpose of substantially altering and remodeling the house thereon in a manner which cannot practicably be done with the tenant in occupancy.”

¶6There was a second count in the information charging that appellant had also violated the Act by having filed a copy of the notice to quit, containing the false statement referred to, with the Minneapolis-St. Paul Defense Rental Area Office.2 On this count, the jury found appellant not guilty. Appellant thereupon filed a motion for a judgment of acquittal on the convicted count notwithstanding the verdict or in the alternative for a new trial, on the ground that the verdict on the separate counts was inconsistent and could not stand. The trial court denied the motions.

¶7Reversal is sought here solhly upon the ground that the conviction on Count I was inconsistent with the acquittal on Count II, because the only question for the jury on each count, under the evidence, was whether the reason stated in the notice to quit for demanding possession was false or true, and that the verdict therefore could not stand but a new trial must be granted.

¶8Prior to Dunn v. United States, 284 U.S. 390, 52 S.Ct. 189, 76 L.Ed. 356, 80 A.L.R. 161, there had been a conflict in the federal courts on whether an inconsistent verdict on the separate counts of an indictment could support a criminal sentence. The Dunn case settled the question, however, when the Supreme Court refused to reverse a conviction for inconsistency in verdict on the separate counts of an indictment, involving the same evidence, and said, 284 U.S. at page 393, 52 S.Ct. at page 190: “Consistency in the verdict is not necessary. Each count in an indictment is regarded as if it was a separate indictment. … If separate indictments had been presented against the defendant for possession [of intoxicating liquor] and for maintenance of a nuisance, and had been *740separately tried, the same evidence being offered in support of each, an acquittal on one could not be pleaded as res judicata of the other. Where the offenses are separately charged in the counts of a single indictment the same rule must hold.”

¶9The Supreme Court has made no departure from this rule. We have most recently repeated and applied it in Pilgreen v. United States, 8 Cir., 157 F.2d 427. The cases upon which appellant relies are all prior to the Dunn case. Inconsistency in a verdict on the separate counts of an indictment or information, then, does not entitle a defendant to a new trial.

¶10The judgment is accordingly affirmed.

/157/f2d/738 · .json · Public domain