Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

158 Ala. 308

Tribble v. Singleton

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided July 15, 1908

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1908-07-15

<p> Bill to Declare a Deed a Mortgage. </p> <p>Mortgages; Ahoslute Deed as Mortgage; Evidence. — The evidence must be clear and conclusive that it was so intended before a deed, absolute on its face, will bo declared to be a mortgage.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1919

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and rendered · Decided 1908-07-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SIMPSON, J.

¶1The bill in this case Avas filed by the appellee to have an absolute deed declared a mortgage.

¶2There is no controversy about the facts that the complainant executed the absolute deed, conveying the property to the defendant, and also signed the lease contract, by Avhich he was to pay so much monthly as'rent for the premises, with the agreement therein expressed that, if he made the monthly payments promptly, a conveyance of the property was to be made to him, but, if not, he was to have no right of purchase; also, that he has not made such payments according to said instrument; also, that complainant can read and write, that he read the lease contract a short time after the copy was delivered to him, and continued to make payments thereunder Avithout making any protest as to its terms.

¶3The testimony of the complainant is in conflict with the testimony of the defendant, but that of the notary who took the acknowledgment tends to support the contention of the defendant.

¶4The testimony is not of that clear and conclusive character Avhich AA’oulcl justify the court in setting aside the plain language of the written instruments, and declaring the deed a mortgage.

¶5The decree of the court is reversed; and a decree will be here rendered dismissing the bill.

¶6Reversed and rendered.

Tyson, C. J., and Dowdell and Denson, JJ., concur
/158/ala/308 · .json · Public domain