Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

159 So. 2d 665

Docket No. 63-390.

Frank v. Levine

Robert R. FRANK, Appellant, v. Hy LEVINE, Lewis Marrow and Dana Marrow, his wife, Appellees.

District Court of Appeal of Florida

Decided January 21, 1964.

District Court of Appeal of Florida · decided 1964-01-21

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“"However, equitable defenses may be pleaded in law actions (rule 1.8(g), Fla.R.C.P., 30 F.S.A.), and there would appear to be no reason why equitable considerations sufficient to limit a deficiency award in equity should not serve equally when pleaded and proved in an action at law to recover a mortgage foreclosure sale deficiency.””

quoted by 2 later decisions, including Maudo, Inc. v. Stein, 615 So. 2d 710 - PMI Mortgage Insurance v. Cavendar

Relies on 95 So. 2d 410 - Hough v. Menses · Taylor, Jr. v. Prine · 97 So. 2d 352 - Stone v. Stone

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1964-01-21

How this case has been cited

Cited by 8 later decisions — most recently January 2017

1 federal appellate · 7 state decisions

40196419701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*666 Frank & Strelkow, Miami Beach, for appellant.

¶2Dorothea M.B. Vermorel, Hollywood, for appellees.

¶3Before CARROLL, HORTON and HENDRY, JJ.

¶4PER CURIAM.

¶5Plaintiff appeals from an order dismissing his complaint. The action was at law for a deficiency following a foreclosure of mortgage. Defendants moved to dismiss on three grounds, (1) that the court lacked jurisdiction of the subject matter, (2) that the "cause of action is res judicata" and (3) that plaintiff had waived his action and was estopped to bring an action at law.

¶6The question presented is whether the complaint stated a cause of action. We hold that it did, and that it was error to dismiss the cause. The contention of want of jurisdiction was without merit. A right of action at law for a deficiency resulting from a mortgage foreclosure sale is expressly conferred by statute. § 702.06, Fla. Stat., F.S.A. Exceptional circumstances which could preclude the action if they existed were not disclosed on the complaint. Res judicata, waiver and estoppel are affirmative defenses. Those defenses and any others available under the facts of the case including equitable defenses should be pleaded in answer to the complaint. Hough v. Menses, Fla. 1957, 95 So.2d 410, 412; Stone v. Stone, Fla.App. 1957, 97 So.2d 352; Nunez v. Alford, Fla.App. 1960, 117 So.2d 208. Cf. Belle Mead Development Corporation v. Reed, 114 Fla. 300, 153 So. 843.

¶7In dismissing the complaint at law for a mortgage foreclosure deficiency, notwithstanding statutory authority for such actions at law, the trial judge may have been motivated by an assumption that equitable considerations which could limit recovery of a deficiency when sought in equity in a foreclosure suit,[1] were not available as equitable defenses or partial defenses in a law action for such a deficiency. However, equitable defenses may be pleaded in law actions (rule 1.8(g), Fla. R.C.P., 30 F.S.A.), and there would appear to be no reason why equitable considerations sufficient to limit a deficiency award in equity should not serve equally when pleaded and proved in an action at law to recover a mortgage foreclosure sale deficiency.

¶8Accordingly the order of dismissal is reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings.

¶9Reversed and remanded.

NOTES

¶10[1] Taylor v. Prine, 101 Fla. 967, 132 So. 464; Carlson v. Becker, Fla. 1950, 45 So.2d 116; Houk v. Weiner, Fla. 1951, 53 So.2d 304; Scheneman v. Barnett, Fla. 1951, 53 So.2d 641; Kissling v. McCarthy, Fla.App. 1958, 100 So.2d 434; Kennedy v. Kay, Fla.App. 1963, 154 So.2d 345; Galloway v. Musgrave, Fla.App. 1963, 154 So.2d 846, 851; 16 U.Miami L.Rev. 745, 749 (1962).

/159/so2d/665 · .json · Public domain