Robertson v. State

Decided June 30, 1917

Alabama Court of Appeals · decided 1917-06-30

L. Brewer, Judge. Mack Robertson was convicted of assault with a weapon, and appeals. This is an appeal from a judgment of conviction upon an indictment returned by the grand jury of Tallapoosa county, charging appellant with the offehse of assault with a weapon.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently October 1922

3 state decisions

Relies on Moore v. State · Brooke v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded · Decided 1917-06-30

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SAMFORD, J.

¶1 The trial court committed error in sustaining the demurrer to the defendant’s plea. Moore v. State, 71 Ala. 307; Brooke v. State, 155 Ala. 78, 46 South. 491. If there was connivance or procurement on the part of the defendant in the judgment rendered in the justice of the peace court, the solicitor .should have set it up by replication.

¶2 Eor the error of the trial court in sustaining the state’s demurrer to the plea, the judgment of the trial court is reversed, and the cause is remanded.

¶3 Reversed and remanded.

Download

Copy

Embed on your site

Hover to preview · click to copy the code

Search Wikipedia →

Status

Disposition: Reversed and remanded

Case posture

Disposition: Reversed and remanded.
Posture: Appeal from Circuit Court, Tallapoosa County; S.L. Brewer, Judge. Mack Robertson was convicted of assault with a weapon, and appeals. Reversed and remanded. This is an appeal from a judgment of conviction upon an indictment returned by the grand jury of Tallapoosa county, charging appellant with the offense of assault with a weapon. The defendant interposed a plea of former jeopardy, which is shown by the record, setting up a conviction in the justice court of Tallapoosa county, upon an affidavit charging an assault, alleging that the assault charged in the affidavit in the justice court is the same assault alleged in the indictment, and that he is the identical person named in the affidavit in the justice of the peace court, and that the justice court had jurisdiction of the offense charged in the said affidavit, and pleading his said conviction in the justice court in bar of this prosecution in the circuit court. The solicitor demurred to this plea, assigning three grounds of demurrer: (1) That the plea failed to aver that the prosecution alleged in the plea was without the connivance or procurement of defendant. (2) That the plea failed to aver that the assault committed by defendant was such an assault as came within the jurisdiction of a justice of the peace. (3) That the plea failed to aver that the assault of which the defendant stands indicted, and of which he pleads he has heretofore been convicted in the justice of the peace court, was an assault in which no stick or other weapon was used. The court sustained the demurrer to the said plea, and the defendant excepted. Upon the trial, the defendant was convicted, and from the judgment of conviction he appeals.

Source: CourtListener

Court

Alabama Court of Appeals

Abolished 1969

Parallel citations

76 So 479