Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

16 N.Y.2d 198

Battista v. Power

New York Court of Appeals

Decided October 28, 1965

New York Court of Appeals · decided 1965-10-28

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently October 2013

Relies on Matter of Crane v. Voorhis · Belford v. Board of Elections · Matter of Aurelio (Cohen)

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1965-10-28

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Burke, J. (concurring).

¶1Under section 248 of the Election Law a candidate who has the nomination of two regular parties is not entitled to a third column on the voting machine under the emblem of an independent body.

¶2All other candidates nominated by independent bodies must each have a separate column before any so-called constitutional or equitable claims can be entertained by the courts. The Board of Elections has by the resolutions in this case repeatedly ignored the explicit language of section 248 of the Election Law. The law as enacted by the Legislature must be enforced (Matter of Nulty v. Board of Elections, 296 N. Y. 645). Since there were separate columns available to all candidates nominated by independent bodies in the cases of Matter of Belford v. Board of Elections (306 N. Y. 70), Matter of Crane v. Voorhis (257 N. Y. 298), and Matter of Aurelio (Cohen) (291 N. Y. 176), the issue of the priorities of candidates nominated by independent bodies was not there involved. Here the Socialist Workers party independent candidates, the Socialist Labor party independent candidates, the United Taxpayers party independent candidates and the Civil Service Fusion party independent candidates must be set forth if possible in the separate columns by the Board of Elections in order to satisfy the mandate of section 248 of the Election Law before any attention can be given to the demands of the Independent Citizens party candidates who have the nomination of more than one regular party. The local candidates of the Independent Citizens party, a political body, who have been nominated by one regular party only, of course, should be treated by the Board of Elections on equal terms with the other independent political bodies such as the Socialist Workers party and Socialist Labor party. The Lindsay candidates (other than those for local offices) must elect upon which of the two party columns they desire the emblem of the independent body to appear (Election Law, § 248; Matter of Nulty v. Board of Elections, 296 N. Y. 645, supra; see Matter *203of Lazer v. McNab, 13 N Y 2d 935). As Judges Fuld and Van Voorhis stated in the dissent in Matter of Belford v. Board of Elections (306 N. Y. 70, 72), “ We see nothing unreasonable in the statute’s preventing his name from being listed also as an ‘ independent ’. ’ ’ In this situation where the candidates of several independent bodies must of necessity be herded together in one column, it is illegal to list the Lindsay candidates nominated by more than one regular party in a separate column as “ independent ”. Such a listing in defiance of the statute relegates candidates of an independent political body not nominated by more than one or any political parties to a catchall column. The statute was enacted to protect independent political bodies without affiliation with the regular political parties. In this case the statute has been flouted and its misuse sought to be justified even though it has resulted in an obvious discrimination against the very independent political bodies the statute was designed to benefit.

¶3The Legislature expected the courts to be alert against the appropriation and monopoly of the lines on the voting machines by the accredited parties in sponsoring independent political parties to the exclusion of the truly independent bodies.

¶4The short time allowed for correction of the ballot errors prevents the ordering of a fair drawing among the qualified groups of candidates nominated by the independent political parties for places in the separate columns. But the shocking treatment dealt out to the supporters of the amendments, the propositions and the question which produces gross inequities in respect to these State-wide referendums can be rectified by removing the Lindsay candidates nominated by more than one regular party from column E. .

¶5Accordingly, the order of the Appellate Division should be reversed.

Fuld, J. (dissenting).

¶6Although Judge Van Voorhis and I dissented in 1953 from the court’s holding in Matter of Belford v. Board of Elections (306 N. Y. 70), that decision does represent the law of this State and I perceive no basis or justification for departing from the rule there clearly announced by the majority —namely, that “ ‘ strict observance of the letter of section 248 [of the Election Law] … would interfere unnecessarily *204with the intelligent and ready expression of his choice by the independent voter ’ ” (p. 73).

¶7In the Belford case, the court was impelled to decide as it did by virtue of the fact that to deny to the independent political body there involved, the United City party, a separate line would tend to discriminate against a large body of independent voters who might refrain from voting for the independent candidate rather than vote for him as a candidate of one of the major parties. In that case it was pointed out that the petitions filed on behalf of the independent political body bore 1,742 signatures — representing some 22% of the electorate—whereas in the present case the petitions of the political body here involved, the Independent Citizens party, contain upwards of 48,000 signatures. In following this court’s decision in Belford, the Appellate Division observed that to refuse a separate line or column to such a body would 1 ‘ work an inequity * # * [and] tend to interfere with a free choice ” by a large number of independent voters. The persons who signed the petitions in the present case represent a far smaller percentage of the electorate, it is true, than did the signers in Belford but the decision in the latter speaks of the unnecessary interference with the expression of choice by the individual “independent voter ” and the number of voters involved here is incomparably greater than those complaining in Belford. (See, also, Matter of Lazer v. McNab, 13 N Y 2d 935, affg. 19 A D 2d 830.)

¶8The integrity of the law demands that the courts refrain from making a special rule for a particular case. I would be willing to vote to overrule this court’s decision in Matter of Belford (306 N. Y. 70, supra) and hold—in line with the view I expressed in dissent in that case — that the respondent Lindsay and his running mates are not entitled to have their names appear in a separate column for the independent political body. However, as long as Belford remains the law of this State, I firmly believe that the court is constrained to follow it. Certainly, the concern which the majority feels for the candidates of the Socialist Workers party and of the Socialist Labor party—none of whom have ever complained about their places on the machine and who (by the present decision) continue in those same places — furnishes no ground for eliminating the separate column which *205the Board of Elections itself actually assigned to the Independent Citizens party some weeks ago.

¶9I would affirm the order appealed from.

/16/ny2d/198 · .json · Public domain