Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

161 Ariz. 65

State v. Prentiss

Court of Appeals of Arizona

Decided February 4, 1988

Court of Appeals of Arizona · decided 1988-02-04

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1989

2 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“We see no distinction between allegations of prior convictions or of the dangerous nature of an offense which, if proven, mandate a prison sentence and the failure to allege mitigating circumstances which then mandates a one-day jail sentence. That form of prosecutorial power is not unconstitutional. State v. Jones, [sic] supra, stands for no more than that a prosecutor cannot control sentencing after conviction, not that his charging decision may not control sentencing discretion.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Prentiss

Relies on State v. Jones · State v. Cummings · State v. Buchholz

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1988-02-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*66OPINION

LIVERMORE, Presiding Judge.

¶2In State v. Jones, 142 Ariz. 302, 305, 689 P.2d 561, 564 (App.1984), we held that the legislature could not, without violating the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, “give the prosecuting attorney the authority, after a conviction, to decide what the punishment shall be.” Accordingly, we found unconstitutional that portion of A.R.S. § 28-692.01(0) permitting the sentencing judge to dispense with a mandatory one-day jail sentence for driving while intoxicated “upon the prosecutor’s recommendation.” The statutory section has since been recast to limit the judge’s ability to dispense with the mandatory jail sentence to those cases where the prosecutor has alleged the mitigating circumstances in that section. The question presented by this appeal is whether State v. Jones requires us to find the amended statute unconstitutional. We agree with the trial court that it does not and affirm.

¶3Prosecutorial discretion to make allegations that may limit a trial judge’s discretion in sentencing does not violate the constitutional separation of powers. State v. Cummings, 148 Ariz. 588, 716 P.2d 45 (App.1985); State v. Buchholz, 139 Ariz. 303, 678 P.2d 488 (App.1983). We see no distinction between allegations of prior convictions or of the dangerous nature of an offense which, if proven, mandate a prison sentence and the failure to allege mitigating circumstances which then mandates a one-day jail sentence. That form of prosecutorial power is not unconstitutional. State v. Jones, supra,stands for no more than that a prosecutor cannot control sentencing after conviction, not that his charging decision may not control sentencing discretion.

¶4Affirmed.

ROLL and FERNANDEZ, JJ., concur.
/161/ariz/65 · .json · Public domain