Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

161 N.C. 314

Church v. Ange

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided February 12, 1913

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1913-02-12

, from judgment rendered by consent at chambers, 20 December, 1912, from WASHINGTON. This is a controversy submitted without action on the following statement of facts: Section 1. Held: used, and enjoyed and disposed of by them for benefit of said church.” Judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiffs, and defendant excepted and appealed.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“Courts of equity have long exercised the jurisdiction to sell property devised for charitable uses, where, on account of changed conditions, the charity would fail, or its usefulness would be materially impaired, without a sale.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including In Re McDonough Trust

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1913-02-12

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently July 1969

8 state decisions

40191319201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

AlleN, J.

¶1The will under consideration contains no restraint upon alienation that the law would not have imposed upon the declaration of trust in favor of Grace Church, as the property is devised in trust, and, in the absence of a power conferred by the will, could not be sold for any other purpose than the one designated, and the language used can have no legal signification except to confer the power to sell.

¶2The language, the property “shall not be disposed of, sold, or used in any other way or for other purpose than the one designated in this clause of my will,” manifests an intention to effectuate the trust, and to permit a sale if the purpose declared, of providing a rectory, can be thereby promoted; but if this power to sell and reinvest in other land, suitable for a rectory, is not contemplated by the will, it is not forbidden, and under the statute, Revisal, see. 2673, the plaintiffs can sell.

¶3If, however, this was doubtful, the sale in this case has the sanction of the court, and courts of equity have long exercised the jurisdiction to sell property devised for charitable uses, *318where, on account of changed conditions, the charity would fail or its usefulness would be materially impaired without a sale. Lockland v. Walker, 52 N. W. (Mo.), 427; Brown v. Baptist Society, 9 R. I., 184; Stanly v. Colt, 72 U. S., 119; Jones v. Habersham, 107 U. S., 183.

¶4In the last case, the Court said of an express provision against alienation: “It will not prevent a court of chancery from permitting, in case of necessity arising from unforeseen change of circumstances, the sale of the land and the application of the proceeds to the purposes of the trust.' Tudor on Charitable Trusts (2d Ed.), 298; Stanly v. Colt, 5 Wall., 119, 169.”

¶5We are of opinion that the sale is valid, and the judgment of the Superior Court is

¶6Affirmed.

/161/nc/314 · .json · Public domain