Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

165 Ala. 257

Papot v. Barbour

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided February 10, 1910

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1910-02-10

Assumpsit. Appeal from Birmingham City Court. Heard before Hon. Charles A. Senn. Action by G. W. Piapot against Ben F. Barbour. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appears. The complaint contained four counts; the first three being on the common counts, and the other declaring on a breach of contract, for the building of a house.

Affirmed · Decided 1910-02-10

McGLELLAN, j.

¶1— Plea 2, wherein it was averred that the approval and acceptance of the work plaintiff had engaged to do should be by the architect named in and as provided by the contract, which had. not been had, was conclusively proven; and hence the court properly gave the affirmative charge for the defendant on that theory.

¶2Plaintiff’s motion for repleader sought a new pleading, notwithstanding he had interposed a demurrer to plea 2, which was overruled. Repleader will not be awarded after demurrer. — 18 Ency. Pl. & Pr. 492; Staple v. Heydon, 6 Modern, Case 1; Andrews’ Stephens Pl. pp. 186, 87; Potter v. Titcomb, 7 Greenl. (Me.) 302; note “e” to Stafford v. Albany, 6 Johns. (N. Y.) 5.

¶3None of the rulings on the evidence related to the matter bearing on the averments of plea 2. The judgment must he affirmed.

¶4Affirmed.

Dowdell, C. J., Concurs, Mayfield and Sayre, JJ., concur in the conclusion.
/165/ala/257 · .json · Public domain