Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

165 Ark. 152

Penix v. Shaddox

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided June 30, 1924

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1924-06-30

Relies on Bowman v. Frith · Law v. Falls

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1924-06-30

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently November 1996

5 state decisions

2019241930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Hart, J.,

¶1(after stating the facts). It is the duty of a county to erect and furnish a courthouse, and to provide necessary offices for the several county officers. Law v. Falls, 109 Ark. 395.

¶2Section 2279 of Crawford & Moses’ Digest defines the powers generally of the county courts of the State. Among other things, the section provides that the county court of each county shall have the control and management of all the property, real and personal, for the use of the county, and to. cause to be erected all buildings and all repairs necessary for the use of the county.

¶3Thus it will be seen that the county court is given not only the authority to furnish a courthouse, but to provide the necessary offices for the several county officers. This includes the power to designate the rooms which are suitable for each particular office, and the action of the county court in assigning the particular rooms which shall be occupied by the different officers is the act of the county. This power is not exhausted when once exercised, but is a continuing one, and the assignment of offices may be changed whenever, in the judgment of the county court, the public convenience will be promoted by the change.

¶4It appears from the record that Shaddox was the sheriff of the county; but he had no right to choose the room which he should occupy as his office. The law confers no authority upon him to take or hold possession of any room in the courthouse for his office when such room has been assigned by the county court to another county officer. The power of the county court is necessarily exclusive. White v. Hewlett (Ala.), 42 So. 78, and eases cited, and Werts v. Feagle (S. C.) 65 S. E. 226.

¶5If the sheriff thought that the county court was acting in an arbitrary manner in assigning offices for the various county officers, he should have made himself a party to the proceeding and have appealed to the circuit court from the order of the county court assigning rooms to the various county officers. The county court had the statutory authority to make the order, and in making it the question of public convenience was involved and determined. A court of equity has no jurisdiction over the subject-matter for the purpose of opening up the question and determining it anew. It is not within the province of equity to correct the error of a county court when proceeding under statutory authority with discretionary powers. Bowman v. Frith, 73 Ark. 523, and White v. Hewlett (Ala.), 42 So. 78.

¶6It is the duty of the sheriff to attend each term of the county court for his county, and execute all orders mad'e by said court. Crawford & Moses’ Digest, § 2272.

¶7In this case it seems that the sheriff himself was the offending party, and refused to obey the order of the county court. All courts have power to issue all writs and process which may he necessary in the exercise of their respective jurisdictions, according to the principles and usages of law. Crawford & Moses’ Digest, § 2104.

¶8Hence the county court might have cited the sheriff for contempt of court in disobeying its orders, or might have enforced it by any other appropriate process. The result of our views is that the wrong remedy was pursued, and the chancery court was without jurisdiction to enforce the order of the county court in question.

¶9It follows that the decree must be affirmed.

/165/ark/152 · .json · Public domain