Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

165 F.2d 782

Docket No. 10517.

Graffius v. Weather-Seal

Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided Jan. 26, 1948.

Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1948-01-26

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently March 1974

2 federal appellate ·

2 counsel of record

Relies on Graffius v. Weather-Seal, Inc.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by (per_curiam) · Decided 1948-01-26

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1See also, D.C., 7 F.R.D. 125.

¶2Scott A. Belden and Charles F. Schnee, both of Akron, Ohio, for appellant.

¶3Albert L. Ely, of Akron, Ohio (Albert L. Ely, Ely & Frye, Bruce W. Bierce, and Brouse, McDowell, May, Bierce & Wort-man, all of Akron, Ohio, on the brief), for appellees.

¶4Before HICKS, ALLEN, and MILLER, Circuit Judges.

¶5PER CURIAM.

¶6Appellant, herein called plaintiff, brought suit against appellees, herein called defendants. The complaint contains seventy-three counts, each of which avers a separate cause of action.

¶7That portion of the statute alleged to-have been violated is the third paragraph of Sec. 4901 R.S., Title 35, U.S.C.A., § 50/gen-erally called the “False Marking” statute.1

¶8It will be observed from the portion of the statute which we have italicized, that, to prove a violation thereof, the plaintiff is required to show, by the weight of the evidence, (1) that there is a false marking upon, or affixation to, an unpatented article of the word “patent” or any word importing that the same is patented, (2) for the purpose of deceiving the public.

¶9The case was heard without the intervention of a jury and at the close of the plaintiff’s evidence the court, following Federal *783Rules of Civil Procedure, rule 41(b), 28 U.S.C.A. following section 723c, dismissed the case upon motion of the defendants. Hence this appeal.

¶10The court found that there was no evidence that the particular frames, window frames or door frames, that are covered in the first seventy-two causes of action, were ever impressed with a print that conveyed a message to the public that these particular articles were patented; and it made a similar finding with reference to the particular items set forth in the seventy-third cause of action.

¶11The court found as a fact — “No testimony was offered by plaintiff which established that any of the doors or windows manufactured by defendant Weather-Seal Manufacturing Company has been marked 'patented’ with the intent to deceive the public.”

¶12An examination of the record discloses that these findings are not “clearly erroneous” and we are not authorized, therefore, to set them aside. Rule 52, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. We must give due regard to the opportunity of the District Court to judge of the credibility of .the witnesses.

¶13Laying other questions presented to one side, the findings dispose of the appeal, and the decree appealed from is affirmed.

/165/f2d/782 · .json · Public domain