Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

166 N.C. 97

81 S.E 1069

Hopkins v. . Crisp

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided May 30, 1914

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1914-05-30

Appeal by defendant from Garter, J., at Spring Term, 1914, of 'Gkaham. This is an action in the nature of an ejectment, tried upon • these issues.: 1. Are the plaintiffs named in the complaint the owners of the land described in the complaint, and entitled to the possession of the same? 2. Is the defendant, Harvey Crisp, in the unlawful jjossession of that part of the land described in his answer ?

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1956

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1914-05-30

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BeowN, J.

¶1 It is admitted that the plaintiffs have shown title in themselves, unless the defendant, Harvey Crisp, has shown title by color and adverse possession. We think the evidence of adverse possession is insufficient. The evidence of the appellant tended to show he had been in possession since 1898. •

¶2 The plaintiffs offered in evidence the record of an action for the recovery of these lands, brought; against John M. Crisp, Harvey Crisp, and Allen Crisp, by summons issued 17 March, 1903. This cause was tried two or three times in Graham, and was removed to Jackson and nonsuited in 1909, and the summons in the present case was issued in 1909.

¶3 From the time he entered in 1898 until the summons was issued, 17 March, 1903, in the case of Archer et al. v. John M. Crisp and Harvey Crisp, was less than seven years. The plaintiffs in that suit were the predecessors in title of Hopkins. The defendant claims he was not served with summons, but the complaint is against the defendant, Harvey Crisp, and all the defendants answered.

¶4 The defendant, Harvey Crisp, proposed to prove that he did not authorize an answer to be filed for him. His Honor properly excluded such evidence. A record of this kind cannot be thus collaterally attacked.

¶5*99 It is well settled that where it appears upon tbe face of tbe record tbat tbe court bad acquired jurisdiction of tbe parties and of tbe subject-matter of tbe action, tbe judgment therein is valid, however irregular it may be, and it must stand until set aside in a proper proceeding by competent authority. England v. Garner, 90 N. C., 197; Harrison v. Hargrove, 120 N. C., 106.

¶6 No error.

/166/nc/97 · .json · Public domain