Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

166 Wis. 48

State ex rel. Pfister v. Widule

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided June 12, 1917

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1917-06-12

J. TueNee, Circuit Judge. This is an appeal from a judgment entered in a certiorari proceeding setting aside assessments of income made in 1916 by the income tax board of review of Milwaukee county and confirmed by the Wisconsin tax commission, on account of income received during the years 1912, 1913, 1914, and 1915 by the stockholders in Prospect Hill Land Company as dividends on their stock in said company.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently April 1935

3 state decisions

Relies on Van Dyke v. City of Milwaukee · State ex rel. Bundy v. Nygaard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed · Decided 1917-06-12

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Eschweileb, J.

¶1(dissenting). I think that what was done in this case was a distribution of property and not of income and that it is squarely within the ruling of this court in State ex rel. Bundy v. Nygaard, 163 Wis. 307, 158 N. W. 87. I do not think that che mere giving of a name to a thing in matters o,f this kind determines its real character either for or against the state. I cannot agree, therefore, with what was said in the case of Van Dyke v. Milwaukee, 159 Wis. 460, 150 N. W. 509, that there is a conclusive presumption as against stockholders that what has been denominated dividends is earnings or profit. Such a presumption may well exist, but it ought not to be a conclusive one, and neither the state nor the individual should be foreclosed from having their respective rights and liabilities determined upon the substance instead of the name of things.

/166/wis/48 · .json · Public domain