Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

167 Mass. 392

Kane v. Shields

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 11, 1897

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1897-01-11

<p>Equity Practice — Decree — Appeal — Report—Voluntary Association — Validity of Vote appropriating Money to Seceding Members.</p> <p>If, in a suit in equity, the evidence is taken and the case reported to this court at the request of the defendants, against some of whom a decree is entered, and as to the others the bill is dismissed, it is not open to the plaintiff, who has not appealed therefrom, to contend that the decree should be modified so as to include among those held liable some of the defendants as to whom the bill was dismissed.</p> <p>A voluntary association cannot, by a vote of a majority of its members voting on the question, lawfully authorize its officers to pay out of the funds of the asso: ciation to certain members who are permitted to secede from it and set up another and a different organization their proportionate share of the property of the association, in the absence of any provision in the constitution and bylaws of the association authorizing such an appropriation of its property, the association not being dissolved by the vote, but continuing to exist the same as before.</p>

Relies on McFadden v. Murphy · Moors v. Washburn

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1897-01-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently December 1958

12 state decisions

301897190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Field, C. J.

¶1This case was heard by a justice of the Superior Court upon the pleadings and evidence, and a decree entered for the plaintiffs against some of the defendants, and the bill dismissed without costs as to the other defendants. The evidence was taken by a commissioner appointed by the court at the request of the defendants.

¶2The plaintiffs’ counsel contends that the decree should be affirmed against the defendants held liable by the Superior Court, and also that it should be modified so as to include among those held liable some of the defendants as to whom the bill was ordered to be dismissed. We are of opinion that this last contention is not open to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs have not appealed from the decree, and it does not appear that they asked to have the case reported. It appears that the evidence was taken and the case reported at the request of the defendants. Although it does- not appear that the defendants have in form appealed from the decree, yet we think that the case as reported should be treated as if the defendants had appealed and the plaintiffs had not. Moors v. Washburn, 159 Mass. 172, 176.

¶3The principal question in the case is whether such an association as is described in the bill and shown by the evidence can, by a vote of a majority of its members voting on the question, lawfully authorize its officers to pay out of the money and funds of the association to certain members who are permitted to secede from it and set up another and a different organization, their pro rata share of the property of the association. The constitution and by-laws of tbe association put in evidence contain no provisions which seem to us to authorize such an appropriation of the property of the association. The association was not dissolved by the vote, but continued to exist the same as before. The case on the evidence falls within the decision in McFadden v. Murphy, 149 Mass. 341. See Altmann v. Benz, 12 C. E. Green, 331.

¶4We are of opinion that the decree should be affirmed.

¶5 So ordered.

/167/mass/392 · .json · Public domain