Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

168 Ala. 45

Whitmore v. State

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 16, 1910

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1910-06-16

Heard before Hon. Alto V. Lee. Jact Whitmore Avas conAdcted of manslaughter in the first degree, and he appeals. In drawing the jury the court followed the usual method employed in capital cases before the adoption of Avliat is known as the “jury law,” and the orders made and the drawing Avas conducted accordingly.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently June 1951

3 state decisions

Relies on Shirley v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1910-06-16

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCLELLAN, J.

¶1The complaint against the method pursued to constitute the jury to try this defendant is *47based, as appears from the brief of counsel, upon the misconception that the jury law, approved August 31, 1909 (Gen. Acts Sp. Sess. 1909, p. 305 et seq.), was in effect when the defendant was tried. For some purposes it was in effect; but by section 17 (page 312) it was postponed, in partial operation and effect, covering the matter the appellant questions on this appeal, until the first Monday in January, 1910.

¶2There is no merit in the criticisms of the organization of the jury for the trial of this defendant.

¶3The refusal, to defendant, of charge 4 accorded with the ruling here on a duplicate of that charge; charge 7 in Shirley v. State, 144 Ala. 35, 42, 40 South. 269.

¶4Charge 5, refused to defendant, is confused, not clear. To what proposition, of the several set forth therein, the concluding sentence had reference is so doubtful as to be misleading. Besides, it omitted in its hypothesis, the bona fide belief of defendant of his peril at the time he shot deceased. The charge probably has other vices.

¶5Charge 3 was well refused. It, like the refused charge 5', omitted, in hypothesis, the bona fide belief of defendant of his peril at the time he shot deceased. It may have other infirmities.

¶6There is no error in the record.

¶7Affirmed.

Simpson, Mayfield, and Evans, JJ., concur.
/168/ala/45 · .json · Public domain