Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

168 N.C. 472

84 S.E 699

Swan v. . Carawan

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided March 24, 1915

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1915-03-24

Appeal by plaintiff from Peebles, J., at October Term, 1914, of Pam-lico. Proceeding to sell land for assets, beard in tbe Superior Court upion appeal from tbe clerk. Tbe only issue submitted to tbe jury was as to tbe indebtedness of tbe intestate. Tbe plaintiff introduced a note and a witness wbo testified tbat be saw tbe deceased execute it.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently October 1958

1 federal appellate · 2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1915-03-24

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

AlleN, J.

¶1 "When the plaintiff proved the-execution of the note by the intestate, he was entitled to have the issue of indebtedness answered in hfs favor unless the defendant established his plea of payment, and the burden of proof upon this plea was on the defendant. Guano Co. v. Marks, 135 N. C., 59.

¶2 It was therefore error to charge the jury that the burden was on the plaintiff to prove that the note had not been paid.

¶3 The witness, Watson, upon whom the defendant relied in support of his plea, admitted on cross-examination that he held a mortgage on the land which the plaintiff was seeking to sell, and it was for the jury and not for the judge to say whether this fact would affect his testimony, and the statement of his Honor that it did not appear that this witness was interested was an expression of opinion upon the weight of evidence which the law does not permit.

¶4 There must be a

¶5 New trial.

/168/nc/472 · .json · Public domain