Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

169 Ala. 460

Phillips v. Morris

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided December 1, 1910

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1910-12-01

<p>1. Witnesses; Competency; Transaction With Decedent. — Where the mortgagor is dead and the suit is in detinue by a mortgagee against one not in privity with the dead mortgagor, the mortgagee is competent to testify as to the amount due on the mortgage, since the estate of the dead mortgagor is not interested in the result of the suit, and section 4007, Code 1907, is without application.</p> <p>2. Appeal and Error; Harmless Error; Evidence. — Where a reasonable attorney’s fee is not within the issue and no recovery is had for such attorney’s fee, any error in admitting evidence thereof is harmless.</p> <p>3. Detinue; Issue; Verdict.- — To support a judgment for the recovery of the property or its alternate value, in detinue, a verdict finding for the plaintiff for $60 for 2,000 pounds of seed cotton and $7.50 for 500 bundles of fodder, shows a sufficient finding for the specific property and the ascertainment of the value thereof.</p> <p>4. Same. — In an action of detinue by a mortgagee against one not in privity with the mortgagor, such an one is not entitled to have the amount of the mortgage debt ascertained under section 3789, Code 1907.</p> <p>5. Same; Insane Person; Instructions. — In an action of detinue by a mortgagee, where there was evidence of the insanity of the mortgagor at the time of the execution of the mortgage, a charge asserting that the presumption of sanity could be rebutted, and that if the jury was reasonably satisfied that the presumption had been overcome, and that the mortgagor was of unsound mind so that he did not understand the subject of the contract and its nature and probable consequences, they must find for the defendant, properly submitted the issues.</p> <p>6. Evidence; Burden of Proof. — The jury need only be reasonably satisfied of the facts on which their verdict was based to justify a finding in a civil case.</p>

Relies on Rowe v. Baber · Harris v. Russell · Behrman v. Newton

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded · Decided 1910-12-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 8 later decisions — most recently May 1945

8 state decisions

401910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

DOWDELL, C. J.

¶1This is an action in detinue for the recovery of specific chattels. The plaintiff bases his title and right of recovery on a mortgage executed by one T. M. Phillips, since deceased.

¶2The first contention in error is that the trial court erred in permitting the-plaintiff against the objection of the defendant to testify as to the amount due on the *463mortgage. This, upon the ground that the mortgagor being dead, plaintiff was incompetent under the statute to testify as to any transaction with the deceased. —Code 1907, § 4007. The contention is without merit. The suit is not one in which the estate of the deceased is interested in the result. The defendant does not pretend to hold in privity with the deceased mortgagor. As between the plaintiff and defendant, the result of the suit would determine nothing as to the interests of the decedent’s estate, and hence his estate could not be interested in the result of the suit. — Snellgrove v. Evans, 165 Ala. 322, 51 South. 560.

¶3The recovery of attorney’s fees was not within the issues, and evidence as to reasonable attorney’s fees was irrelevant and inadmissible; but as no recovery was had for such fees, the error of admitting this evidence was harmless.

¶4While the verdict of the jury might have been more •definitely expressed, we think it sufficiently shows a finding for the specific property sued for and for the ascertainment of the alternate value of the articles, respectively, to support the judgment.

¶5The defendant not being the mortgagor, nor his transferee, nor holding under him, was not entitled to have the mortgage debt ascertained, under the provisions of the statute. — Code 1907, § 3789.

¶6That part of the oral charge of the court set out in the bill of exceptions, and to which an exception was reserved, was error. To justify a verdict in a civil case, no more is required than that the jury should be reasonably satisfied of the facts upon which the verdict was based. — Rowe v. Baber, 93 Ala. 422, 8 South. 865; Behrman v. Newton, 103 Ala. 525, 15 South. 838; Harris v. Russell, 93 Ala. 68, 9 South. 541; 3 Mayfield’s Digest, p. 598, § 3198, also p. 600, § 3236.

¶7*464There was evidence tending to show the insanity of T. M. Phillips when he executed the mortgage, and under the issues on this phase of the evidence, we think that charge 1, requested by the defendant, correctly stated the law and should have been given, and that its refusal constituted reversible error.

¶8For the error indicated, the judgment must be reversed.

¶9Reversed and remanded.

Simpson, McClellan, and Mayfield, JJ., concur.
/169/ala/460 · .json · Public domain