Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

169 Misc. 905

People v. Berkey

New York County Court, Kings County

Decided January 26, 1939

New York County Court, Kings County · decided 1939-01-26

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1941

1 state decisions

Relies on People v. Zambounis · People v. McCarthy · People v. Jackerson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1939-01-26

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Fitzgerald, J.

¶1It is stated in the moving affidavit that by direction of a grand jury, approved by the court, the district attorney has filed an information in the Court of Special Sessions against defendant.

¶2The purpose of the inspection is stated to be to enable defendant to make a motion to dismiss the information because the testimony before the grand jury is insufficient to sustain the information.

¶3No such procedure is known to the law. (People v. May, 158 Misc. 488.)

¶4Section 742 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states what an information must recite.

¶5*906If the facts alleged do not set forth a crime, the information should be dismissed. (People v. Zambouris, 251 N. Y. 94, 97; People ex rel. Jones v. Langan, 132 App. Div. 393.)

¶6So, also, if there is a variance between the information and proof (People v. McCarthy, 250 N. Y. 358), although certain variances may be waived. (People v. Jackerson, 247 N. Y. 36.)

¶7This is not a motion to inspect for the purpose of having the order directing the district attorney, to proceed by information vacated.

¶8Such motions present a different question.

¶9The court does not agree with the conclusion reached in People v. Levine (161 Misc. 336). There the district attorney conceded the court’s authority; here it is challenged.

¶10People v. Tumen (161 Misc. 645) does not apply.

¶11Motion denied.

/169/misc/905 · .json · Public domain