Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

17 Abb. N. Cas. 395

Halsey v. Gerdes

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1886

New York Supreme Court · decided 1886-05-15

Demurrer to complaint. Fanny Halsey sued John F. Gerdes in ejectment for certain premises in the city of New York. . The complaint alleged ‘1 That the plaintiff is seized in fee of the following described premises (describing them). That the defendants are in possession thereof and withhold the same from her,” and demanded judgment: I. For the possession of said premises. II. For the sum of $1,000, plaintiff’s damages by the withholding of the same.”

Relies on Payne & Dewey v. Treadwell · Jenkins v. . Fahey · Walter v. Lockwood

Decided 1886-05-15

Barrett, J.

¶1—The case upon which defendants rely (Moores v. Lehman, 52 Super. CL [J. & S.] 283), is not supported by the authorities. It is well settled that an allegation of “seizin in fee,” followed by an averment of an unlawful withholding, is sufficient on .general demurrer (Ensign v. Sherman, 14 How. Pr. 439; Sanders v. Leavy, 16 How. Pr. 308; Walter v. Lockwood, 23 Barb. 228). Here the word “ unlawfully ” is omitted, but it may be treated as a conclusion of law or as surplusage (Payne v. Treadwell, 16 Cal. 220). The averment of seizin in fee is equivalent to an averment of the right to immediate possession (1 Washb. Real Prop. 58; Jenkins n. Fahey, 73 N. Y. 355, 361, and cases there cited ; Bouvier's Law Dict.; Abb. *397Law Dict.). The plaintiff being entitled to immediate possession, as implied from the seizin in fee, the defendant’s possession and withholding are necessarily wrongful. If otherwise, they must set up the facts from which they claim the right to withhold and retain possession.

¶2The demurrer must be overruled with costs, and with leave to defendants to answer within twenty days, upon payment of such costs.

/17/abbncas/395 · .json · Public domain