¶1Two questions only have been argued to any considerable extent, upon the appeal in this cause. First: Whether the act of April 16,1852, “ to facilitate the dissolution of manufacturing corporations in the county of Herkimer, and to secure the payment of their debts without preferences,”
¶2I. “The act to facilitate the dissolution of manufacturing corporations in the county of Herkimer,” was manifestly designed by the legislature to save the expense and delay incident to proceedings at law in the dissolution and winding up of insolvent corporations ; and also, to give the same remedy to creditors of those institutions which would be granted by a court of equity. Both of these objects are clearly shown by the very title of the act, and are equally apparent on the face of the statute. In many of its provisions the act in question "bears a close analogy to the act entitled “ of the voluntary dissolution of corporations,” especially to that part of it which *123relates to the appointment and the duties of receivers of such corporations. (See 2 R. S. 711 to 714, 4th ed.) This latter act, however, does not undertake “ to secure the payment of the debts due from such corporations, without preferences,” and it contains nothing in its title and nothing on its face that indicates such an intent: on the contrary, it vests the receiver with 11 all the estate, real and personal, of such corporationbut it does not interfere with the rights of creditors under the seventh section of the act of 1811. (See 2 R. S. 4th ed. 711, § 77, [67].) It authorizes them to bring actions for arrears of unpaid stock, against the stockholders, but it does not attempt to clothe them with authority to collect, in addition to arrears of stock, what may be due from such stockholders, as a liability for the corporation’s debts. (Sec. 79, [69].) The reason for this distinction is apparent; it wras not the intention of the act to vest in the receivers any thing but the property of the corporation, strictly speaking. The liability for corporation debts belonged to creditors, and not to the corporations-. In truth, the receiver of the property of a manufacturing corporation could not take (except by an enactment containing words •which fairly conferred them,) the rights of creditors under the seventh section of the act of 1811.
¶3The third section of the act declares the duties of the trustees ; and by a necessary implication vests the title to the entire fund in them. They are directed with all reasonable diligence “ to close the business ; dispose of the property; collect all debts and liabilities, assess deficiences, if necessary, upon stockholders to the extent of their liability, and collect the same; pay the debts of the company in equal ratio, and make distribution of any surplus among the stockholders,” &c. The clause directing the assessment of deficiencies, if necessary, upon the stockholders to the extent of their liability, is supposed by the counsel of the plaintiff to refer to the liability of the stockholders for unpaid stock. This construction, however, is not warranted by any just rule of interpretation. First. The words “ assess deficiencies ” would be a very awkward expression, when applied to subscriptions for stock. There would ordinarily be no assessment, but a suit would be brought for the whole of the unpaid stock. In truth the whole of the stock should be collected in at first. Its capital stock is the fund with which the corporation commences business, and on which the creditor who deals with the company mainly relies. By the first section of the act, the trustees must be satisfied that the assets of the company, over and above its capital stock, are insufficient to pay its debts, before they are at liberty to declare the corporation dissolved. The stock must all be paid in or collected. This was one of the first duties enjoined on the receiver of an insolvent *128corporation by the statute. (2 R. S. 711, § 79, [69, 4th ed.] See also Shepard v. Cushman, 4 Barb. 119, and cases there cited.) Therefore, the injunction to assess deficiences, if necessary, to the extent of the liability of the stockholders, is absurd, when applied to an insolvent corporation: because the resolution declaring its dissolution can only be passed on the hypothesis that it is necessary; and when the very idea of insolvency presupposes the necessary exhaustion of the entire capital stock. Secondly. The phrase “assess deficiences, if necessary, upon stockholders, to the extent of their liability,” is almost identical with the words employed in the seventh section of the act of 1811, to describe the liability to.creditors, now under consideration. Thirdly. The direction to ^assess deficiences,” occurs precisely in the order of time, when it should, if the construction we have adopted be the true one. By the previous clauses of the third section the trustees are directed to collect all debts and liabilities due to the corporation, and to dispose of its property, and close the business. This should all be done before the stockholders are required to advance any thing upon this personal liability requirement; and then they should be required to pay upon it no more than may be necessary to satisfy the debts due to the creditors of the company. And again, in obedience to the rule in chancery, they should pay, in equal ratio, to the amount of stock held by them respectively; as much as is necessary to satisfy the creditor, up to the extent of their liability; in other words, to the extent of the shares of stock which they hold, at the dissolution of the corporation. These considerations are conclusive with us, as to the true construction of this act. It is true that the act is not drawn with a great degree of perspicuity or precision; but the reasons in favor of the interpretation we have felt bound to give to it, seem to us to place the questions beyond any reasonable doubt.
¶4II. The next question we propose to examine is, whether the act of 1852 violates that provision of the constitution which prot Mbits the passage of any law that impairs the obligation of contracts. The principle to be maintained by the party who holds the affirmative of this proposition is, that the obligation imposed *129on the stockholder by the seventh section of the act of 1811, is founded on contract. We do not here speak of the original obligation of the corporation to the creditor; for that springs directly out of a contract. If the obligation was upon those persons who were members of the company when the corporation contracted the debt; and if the obligation was to pay the whole amount of the debt, there would be more propriety in saying that the stockholders might be considered as parties to the contract, when it was made; in the light of sureties or guarantors of the corporation; such was the case in Corning v. McCullough, (1 Comst. 47.) But even in that case, it is not said that the obligation is founded on contract, in any sense, except to avoid the statute of limitations against penalties and forfeitures. The opinion holds that a declaration might be framed on the obligation, setting out the facts, as in a special action on the case. It does not assert, however, that an action of assumpsit would lie against the defendants upon the obligation, even in that case. It was only by a remote analogy that it bore any relation to a contract. But in the .case under consideration the provision of the statute, the obligation of the stockholders ■; and the rights of the creditors, are altogether different. The stockholder cannot be said to stand in the relation of surety or guarantor of the contract which the creditor made with the corporation, for two reasons ; (1.) the obligation does not rest upon those who were members of the company when the debt was contracted; but on those who were members when the corporation was dissolved; (2.) the obligation is not commensurate with the debt of the creditor; but it is limited by the extent of the shareholder’s interest in the capital stock. So that the contract that is impaired is, in no sense, the contract of the creditor with the corporation. It is not similar to that in any of its features. The parties, the date, the amount, the nature of the obligation and the foundation on which it rests are all different. Even the a. debt ” against the corporation may be a judgment sounding in tort; but jet the stockholder is under the same obligation to pay it, to the extent of his liability, that he would be if it had rested in con-*130tract. To every contract there must be two parties capable of contract. Here, one of the parties must be the stockholder,, who is such at the moment of dissolution. The other, is the creditor who happens to own the demand against the corporation at the same moment. The one may have bought the demand and the other the stock, an hour before, and the obligation to pay is wholly irrespective of the amount of the creditor’s demand, or of the nature of it, whether it be an open contract or a judgment for a tort. The contract then (if any there be,) must be entirely independent of the original debt of the corporation. It must be a contract precisely in the words which the statute has carved out. Now then can that obligation be a contract within the meaning of the constitution? It is not binding on the party because he has contracted or agreed to pay ; but because the statute has enjoined it upon him as a duty. It is true that in an enlarged sense, every citizen, when he enters into the social compact that lies at the foundation of every political society, agrees to obey the laws; and in that sense the obligation to pay a penalty, or to suffer a punishment prescribed by an act of §he legislature, maybe said to be founded on contract j but it is-needless to say that such is not the interpretation of the word “ contract,” as used in the constitution. That instrument refers to the obligation on parties founded on their practical agreement, to do, or not to do, a particular thing, and not on a mere theoretical contract. Now, under this view of the nature of the obligation, it seems to us a great stretch of construction to say, that the obligation on the stockholder is founded on a contract. It appears, on the contrary, to spring from, and to rest upon, the enactment of the statute solely. It is a duty, because the statute has enjoined it, and not because the parties have entered into a contract to perform it. Judge Story says, (1 Mason, 243,) “ Whatever is enjoined by a statute to be done creates a duty on the party, which he is bound to perform. When, therefore, a statute declares that a stockholder in- a bank shall pay the debt due from the bank under certain circumstances, and those circumstances occur, it creates a direct and immediate obligation to pay it.” So, it seems to us, that it is the statute *131and not a contract, which creates the obligation in the present ease.
¶5But we do not decide this question; nor is our decision placed on this ground. It is not necessary; for there can be no just pretense-that the act of 1852 either impairs or even changes the obligation of the stockholder under the seventh section of the act of 1811. That obligation is not to pay one creditor, to the exclusion of the rest; nor to pay any creditor the amount of his debt, absolutely. It is to devote a'particular fund, (viz.) an amount equal to the stockholder’s share of stock, to the payment of “ all the debts due and owing by the company at the time of its dissolution.” Ho single creditor has a vested right to be paid his debt in preference to any others. It is true that one creditor may sue for his debt in an action at law, and get
¶6J3 because, either there is no other cred-disposed to take%ny action -'tdt-arrest his suit; or that a court of law does not allow the making of the proper parties to raise the question and adjust the fund between those who are entitled to it. But suppose two creditors bring separate suits against a stockholder, each for an amount equal to his capital stock; he may file a bill of interpleader, or any other creditor may successfully invoke the jurisdiction of ’chancery, to stay all proceedings at law, and have the entire fund ' distributed pro rata, in accordance with the true spirit of the act. (See 4th Barb. 118, 390, 393; 8th Cowen, 387; Hopk. 305; 10 Paige, 592; 24 Wend. 479; 19 John. 450, 472.) What we desire to say is, that the construction the court of chancery gives to the obligation prescribed in the act of 1811, is the true construction; it declares and adjusts the liability precisely according to the statute, by devoting the fund ■ to the payment ofall the debts due from the corporation&c. in obedience to the express injunction of the statute itself. And the court of chancery will control the actions of a court of law, (which from its organization can only decide between two parties,) whenever its jurisdiction is properly invoked, and it may always be invoked when there is any other party, who is interested in the fund; and whose rights are endangered by the suit at *132law: Now, it is presumed that the act of 1852 proposes to do in a summary way, precisely what the court of chancery would always do, when its power was invoked; and that, instead Of imposing the obligation that rests on the stockholders, it enforces it, in precisely the manner, to accomplish the object manifest on the face of the statute. This is all we de'em it necessary to say on this subject; and as no other questions were argued before us, we feel bound to declare our opinion to be in favor of affirming the judgment.
¶7Gridley, W. F. Allen, Hubbard and Pratt, Justices.]
¶8Laws of 1852, p. 572.
¶9 1 R, S. 4th ed. 1211.