Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

17 How. Pr. 90

Bean v. Renway

New York Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1858

New York Supreme Court · decided 1858-12-15

<p>This case presents a purchase of goods upon false representations, (not unfrequent in the city of New-York,) upon these facts:</p> <p>The goods were sold, by the plaintiff to defendant Wells, upon a credit of six months, upon the representations of defendant Renway, that Weils was good and responsible to the extent of §800 to §1,000. That he was a prudent and careiulman, worth $2,000 to $3,000, and owed very little if anything, and that he was every way responsible and worthy of credit.</p> <p>When the fact was, that at the time of the purchase, Wells was considerably in debt, and in reality insolvent, and Ronway knew it, for among other debts of Wells, was a judgment against him in favor of Renway, for §1,000, docketed only one month previous to the purchase, and upon which an execution was issued and put in the hands of an officer, and on the arrival of the goods from N e w-Y ork, and before they reached Wells’ store, the execution was fastened upon them by a familiar proceeding called a levy. Judgment was rendered for plaintiff with costs.</p>

Decided 1858-12-15

By the court—Sutherland, Justice.

¶1There is a good cause of action stated in the complaint against the defendant Renway, to which he appeared and answered, and the issue was referred to A. K. Hadley, Esq., who reported in favor of the plaintiff. The report of the referee, and the judgment entered " thereon, were abundantly justified by the case and the evidence. The evidence in the case, to which no objection was made, appears to us to have been abundantly sufficient to authorize the conclusion to which the referee arrived. And we are at a loss to see upon what ground the defendant Renway, expected this court to set aside the report of the referee.

¶2The judgment entered on the report of the referee must he affirmed with costs.

¶3Note.—The merchants in the city of New-York, it is pretty generally understood, are very frequently the victims of this fraudulent and to some extent systematic reducing process. And the courts in the city appear to understand and intend from the frequency of such cases, that no mock trials or judgments will be tolerated in reference to them, and that each successive case of the kind will have a tendency to nerve the arm of justice, and insure a more powerful blow upon the bead of the offender, so that the practice will probably become extra hazardous, besides being in the end extremely inconvenient to pursue,—[Repobteb.

/17/howpr/90 · .json · Public domain