Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

17 Ind. 220

Kohler v. Montgomery

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided December 4, 1861

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1861-12-04

<p>gu¡(. Up0n a promissory note made payable in a bank, against the m ker and indorser, aveiring due presentment, protest and notice. The note was dated February 3, 1860, and was payable one hundred and twenty dnys after date. The indorsor answered by general denial. It appeared in evidence, on the trial, that the note was presented for payment, and protested for non-payment, on Jane 5, 1860.</p> <p>Held, that the presentment and protest were premature by one day, as the month of February, commercially speaking, never has more than twenty-eight days.</p> <p>Held, also, there being no allegation or proof as to whether the makers had money, or not, at the place of payment on June 6, that a case was not made out against the indorser.</p> <p>Held, also, that if the protest and notice v ere not regarded as part of the complaint, then the averment of due presentment and protest was good; if they were so regarded, then the complaint did not show a legal demand and notice of non-payment, and the defect might be taken advantage of by the indorser on appeal.</p>

Relies on Blacklege v. Benedick · Spangler v. McDaniel

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-12-04

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently March 1899

4 state decisions

201861187018801890decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Perkins, J.

¶1Lutz dé Lpjjiler made a note, payable at a bank, to Kohler. The note was dated February 3, 1860, and was payable one hundred and twenty days after date. Koh'er indorsed the note to the plaintiff. The complaint, which is against the maker and indorser, avers that the note was duly presented for payment, &c., but does not name the day when, &c. Lm1z c6 Tjpffler made default. Kohler put in the general denial. Trial; judgment for the plaintiff.

¶2The proof was that demand of payment, and notice of nonpayment, so far as there were any, were made on June 5,1860. This was premature, by one day. Commercially, February never has but twenty-eight days. Iud. Dig., p. 763. See Story on Bills, § 320, as to excluding the day of date in the computation of time.

¶3There were no allegations nor proofs as to whether the 'makers had money at the place of payment on June 6, the day when payment was to be made, or not. A case, there-fore, was not made out against Kohler, on the trial. See Spangler v. McDaniel, 3 Ind. 275.

¶4But it is contended that as no demurrer was put in to the *221complaint, the question of the proper time of making demand of payment cannot be raised on appeal.

John II. S.otmiburg and T. M. Brown, for the appellant.W. T Otto, for the appellee.

¶5If the protest and notice are not a part of the complaint in this case, (and it was not necessary to make them so,) the complaint does not show the day when demand was made, as it simply avers that it was duly made, and hence a demurrer would not have raised the question. If, on the other hand, the protest and notice were, in this case, made a part of the complaint, they did not cause it to show a legal demand and notice of non-payment, and this defect may be taken advantage of on appeal, by the indorser. Blacklege v. Benedick, 12 Ind. 389.

¶6Per Curiam.. — The judgment is reversed, with costs. Cause remanded, with leave to amend, &c.

/17/ind/220 · .json · Public domain