Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

17 La. Ann. 22

Haughery v. Lee

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided May 15, 1865

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1865-05-15

A PPEAL from the Sixth District Court of New Orleans, Howell, J. In a contract of lease, three things are absolutely necessary, to wit: The thing, the price, and the consent. C. C. 2640. And, by C. C., Art, 2639, the price must bej&ed Art. 2641. The price should be certain and determinate, and, if left to a third person named and determined * * * if he cannot or will not do it, there is no hiring.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1865-05-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently December 1985

5 state decisions

201865187018801890190019101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Labatjve, J.

¶1This case involves a pure question of law, which must be examined 'and decided upon the face of the papers.

¶2The plaintiff, after having alleged the indebtedness of the defendant to her, in the sum of $820, states, as the consideration of the debt, “that said Lee, on or about the 20th day of October, 1859, went into possession of a residence, situated on Seventh street, between Náyades and Prytania streets, in the Fourth District of this city, and belonging to petitioner, on 'an understanding with petitioner that he should pay her a reasonable rent forsaid premises. ” ‘

¶3At the same timé, she prayed and obtained upon her affidavit a provisional seizure against the furniture and effects of the defendant, as in a case of lease. ■

¶4The defendant, on motion, obtained a rule upon the plaintiff to show cause, oh.the 10th of January 1861, at 10 o’clock, A. M., why tho writ of provisional seizure herein-issued, should not be set aside, on the grounds :

¶51. That the affidavit, upon which the saijl writ was issued,'does not show that the amount claimed is for rent of the premises described in the petition.

¶62. It does not show that^ there was any lease of said premises to defendant.

¶73. That the claim, as set forth in the petition, is based upon the mere occupancy by defendant, of the premises, which does not give rise to such relations between the parties as to authorize a provisional seizure.

¶8A fourth ground to the insufficiency of the affidavit, which it is unnecessary to notice.

¶9* The District Judge made the rule absoluto, and set aside the provisional seizure, with costs, The plaintiff appealed from that judgment.

¶10*23This rule is in tlie nature of a motion made on thé facé of the papers, thereby taking for true the allegations, for the purpose of trying the rule.

¶11The question is, then, whether or not the understanding to paya reasonable-' renlis afixeclprice, a-pAae certain wid determínale. C. C: Arts.-2639-2641. We think there was no price fi. vedliy ths parties, as contemplated by law, nor' was the price left to a third person named and determined. C. C. Art. 2642. If anything, it was left to be fixed by a person not designated, to persons called as witnesses in the suit to say what was a reasonable price;. and then there might have been as many different prices as there 'were witnesses ; therefore, there being no price fixed by the parties, or left to' the award of a third person named and determined, the'a¿reeifient wanted", an essential ingredient to constitute a contract of lease.' 0. 'C. Art. 2640.

¶12It is therefore adjudged and decreed that the judgment of the lower Court be affirmed, with costs. ;

Howell, J., being the Judge who decided the case bélow, took no .part in this decision. ' 'Jones, J., absent.
/17/laann/22 · .json · Public domain