Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

17 Mass. 417

Dean v. Williams

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 15, 1821

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1821-10-15

This was a suit to foreclose a mortgage. The only question in the case was on the mode of computing the interest due on the note, to secure the payment of which the mortgage was made; and it was agreed by the parties, that if the Court should be of opinion that the amount due was not greater than a certain sum mentioned in the agreement, the plaintiff should discontinue his suit; but if a greater amount was due, the conditional judgment prescribed by the statute, should be…

Relies on Stoughton v. Lynch · Tillotson v. Preston · Penrose v. Hart

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1821-10-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 23 later decisions — most recently July 1977

23 state decisions — followed in 11 states

501821183018401850186018701880189019001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court.

¶1—One of the methods of casting interest where partial payments have been made and endorsed on bonds, notes, or other securities for money, is to calculate the interest from the date of the security, or the time when the interest is to commence, to the time of the first payment endorsed, to add this to the principal, and from the sum to subtract the payment. On this remainder interest is cast to the time of the second endorsement, which is added to the remainder, and from the sum is subtracted the second endorsement. In like manner interest is cast from one payment to another, and to the time of the judgment. This method is correct, whenever the payment exceeds the amount of interest due at the time of payment; but is not to be used when the interest exceeds the payment; for the effect, in such case, would be to give compound interest, which the law does not allow.

¶2To avoid this, the following rule has been adopted, by which every payment is first applied to keep down the interest ; * but the interest is never allowed to form a part [ * 418 ] of the principal, so as to carry interest.

¶3Compute the interest on the principal sum, from the time when the interest commenced to the first time when a payment was made, which exceeds, either alone, or in conjunction with the preceding payments, if any, the interest at that time due; add that interest to the principal, and from the sum subtract the payment made at that time, together with the preceding payments, if any; and the remainder forms a new principal, on which compute and subtract the in*338terest, as upon the first principal; and proceed in this manner to the time of the judgment.

¶4By this rule the interest has been computed in the case before us; and the balance, found due, having been paid to the plaintiff, he has leave to discontinue, and no costs are to be taxed for the tenant (1).

¶5 [See the various decisions on this subject, Fay vs. Bradley, 1 Pick. 194.— Williams vs. Haughtaling, 3 Cowen, 87, and note to this case.—Tillotson vs. Preston, 3 Johns. 229.—Scarland & Al. vs. Houston, 5 Yergor, 310.—Meredith vs. Banks, 1 Halst. 408.—Lamott vs. Starrett, 1 H. & Johns. 42.—Bunn vs. Moore, 1 Hayw. 279. —Tracy vs. Wikoff, 1 Dall. 124.—Penrose vs. Hart, 1 Dall. 378.—State of Connecticut vs. Jackson, 1 Johns. Ch. C. 13.—Stoughton vs. Lynch, 2 Johns. Ch. 209.—Church vs. Norwich, Kirby, 140.—Lightfoot vs. Price, 4 H. M. 479.—Smiths vs. Shaw, 2 Wash. C. C. R. 167.—Doe vs. Warren & Al. 7 Greenl. 49.—Ed.]

/17/mass/417 · .json · Public domain