Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

176 Ala. 451

McGraw v. Tillery

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided April 18, 1912

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1912-04-18

Equity Court. Heard before Hon. W. F. Dickinson, Special Judge. Petition by T. P. Hudmon against T. J. Tillery, as administrator, and others. From a judgment overruling demurrers to the petition, certain defendants appeal.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1930

2 state decisions

Relies on Ex parte Printup · Renfro Bros. v. Goetter, Weil & Co. · Talladega Mercantile Co. v. Jenifer Iron Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded · Decided 1912-04-18

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCLELLAN, J.

¶1T. P. Hudmon became by purchase from heirs or distributees, entitled to share in the estate of John C. Tillery, deceased. By petition, which the reporter will summarize, he sought to charge the shares of others in the estate with his reimbursement of the sum alleged to have been expended by him. It must be concluded, from the averments of the petition, that the sums so alleged to have been paid out were not expended, in any legal sense, in the interest or for the benefit of the estate, but, to the contrary, for the individual benefit or advantage of those entitled to share therein. That being the nature and objective of the rights or claims the petitioner would assert and enforce, his remedy was and is by original or supplemental bill, and not by petition to intervene in the administration cause, as was his effort. — Ex parte Printup, 87 Ala. 148, 6 South. 418; Renfroe v. Goetter, 78 Ala. 314; Talladega Mercantile Co. v. Jenifer Iron Co., 102 Ala. 259, 14 South. 743. The alleged rights or claims of petitioner are, necessarily, independent of those determinable within the proper sphere of the chancery process of administration of an estate. The court erred, therefore, in overruling the demurrers to the petition.

¶2Reversed and remanded.

All the Justices concur.
/176/ala/451 · .json · Public domain