Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

178 F. 918

Docket No. 58 (1,346).

The Marshall O. Wells

Third Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided May 4, 1910.)

Third Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1910-05-04

Suit in admiralty by Jacob Elzer, Sr., administrator of the estate of Rudolph Elzer, against the schooner Marshall O. Wells. Decree for libelant (172 Fed. 984), and claimant, the Perth Amboy Dry Dock Company, appeals.

2 counsel of record

Relies on The Marshall O. Wells

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1910-05-04

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently December 1994

2 federal appellate · 1 district ·

20191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Collision (§ 69*) — Schooner Running Down Fishing Boat — Application op Rules to Motob Boat.

¶2Article 26 of the inland navigation rules (Act June 7, 1897, c. 4, 30 Stat. 102 [U. S. Comp. St. 1901, p. 2883]), which provides that “sailing vessels under way shall keep out of the way of sailing ve'ssels or boats fishing with nets or lines or trawls,” applies to a fishing boat having motor power ; and a schooner is liable for the death of a person caused by her negligently running down a motor boat while at anchor and fishing in a place which left ample fairway.

¶3[Ed. Note. — -For other cases, see Collision, Cent. Dig. § 88½; Dec. Dig. § 69.*]

¶4Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the District of New Jersey.

¶5Suit in admiralty by Jacob Elzer, Sr., administrator of the estate of Rudolph Elzer, against the schooner Marshall O. Wells. Decree for libelant (172 Fed. 984), and claimant, the Perth Amboy Dry Dock Company, appeals.

¶6Affirmed.

¶7James D. Dewell, for appellant.

¶8_ Frank Carpenter, for appellee. '

¶9_ ' Before BUFFINGTON and LANNING, Circuit Judges, and ARCHBALD, District Judge.

¶11BUFFINGTON, Circuit Judge.

¶12This is an appeal by the owner of the schooner Marshall O. Wells from a decree in admiralty adjudging her liable to Jacob Elzer, Sr., administrator of Rudolph Elzer, in damages for the latter’s death. The opinion of the court below, reported at 172 Fed. 984, discusses both facts and law so fully and satisfactorily *919that an opinion here would he mere repetition. It suffices to say that, after a thorough examination of the record, we agree wholly with the findings and conclusions of the court below.

¶13The proofs satisfy us that decedent’s power boat was anchored for fishing in a proper place and in plain view of the approaching schooner; that there was ample fairway room for the latter to pass; that a horn was blown on the fishing boat as the schooner approached; that the power boat was in no fault; that the schooner could have seen the fishing boat and heard the horn in ample time to avoid the collision, had she had a lookout. By rule 26 (Act June 7, 1897, c. i, 30 Stat. 102 [U. S. Comp. St. 1901, p. 2883]), providing that “sailing vessels under way shall keep out of the way of sailing vessels or boats fishing with nets, or lines or trawls,” the schooner was in fault in making no effort to avoid decedent’s fishing boat, which, as we have seen, left ample fairway space for the schooner.

¶14It is contended, however, that rule did not apply to decedent’s fishing boat, because it had motor power. The purpose of rule 26 is to safeguard boats generally at places where they are properly engaged in fishing. The rule makes no distinction between the kinds of fishing craft. The use of motors in such boats has been general for several years, and the fact that no change has been made in the rule argues strongly against the construction urged. But, apart from this, we think such a construction would tend to confusion and danger. A vessel approaching “vessels or boats fishing with nets, or lines or trawls,” can see they are fishing and avoid them; but, if its duty toward them is to be determined by the presence or absence o E a motor, confusion may readily occur when the vessel is anchored or drifting, for the motor may be so installed as not to be seen, it may be out of order, or, as happens, it may have run out of gasoline. Uncertainty as to the purposes of approaching vessels is a most frequent cause of collision. The construction here contended for would breed an uncertainty that rules and courts should avoid.

¶15The decree should be affirmed.

/178/f1d/918 · .json · Public domain