Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

178 Wash. 165

34 P.2d 437

In Re Bruener

Washington Supreme Court

Decided July 9, 1934

Washington Supreme Court · decided 1934-07-09

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1934-07-09

How this case has been cited

Cited by 13 later decisions — most recently June 2001

12 state decisions

4019341940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Brake, J.

¶1 (dissenting) — The holding here is essentially predicated on the theory that the judgment of disbarment was wrong from the beginning; that peti *169 tioner’s offense merited, as contended by the minority in the disbarment proceedings, no more than three years suspension. I could agree to this if the offense were only an affair with a woman. The offense, however, is essentially more grave than that. The woman in the case was not only a woman — she was a juror in the cause in which petitioner was taking an active part as counsel. For the time, she personified the blindfolded goddess. When he, who was sworn to guard, violated the chastity of Justice, judgment of disbarment followed of necessity — not to punish him but to vindicate Tier honor. By their unanimous report, the board of governors have expressed their belief that that judgment must stand, in order that the accomplished vindication may be sustained. I can but agree with that view.

¶2 Comparisons are said to be odious — possibly because they make inequalities to appear so glaring. To undertake to do comparative justice is not a sound or practicable principle for courts to act upon. Yet Lord Mansfield said: “It is almost as important that justice appear to be done as it is that justice actually be done.” On the same day that petitioner’s application for reinstatement was heard, the court had before it the unanimous recommendation of the board of governors for the suspension, for one year, of an attorney whose talents, standing and prominence at the bar were not in any degree comparable to petitioner’s. That attorney’s offense consisted in using, under the stress of dire economic necessity, a few dollars belonging to his clients. In his case the recommendation of the board of governors was adopted by the court. Although at the time of hearing he had made complete restoration, I hold no brief in extenuation of his offense. But, by comparison, I cannot bring *170 myself to believe that these “judgments are true and righteous altogether.”

/178/wash/165 · .json · Public domain