Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

179 N.C. 678

103 S.E 374

Culbreth v. . Martin

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided June 2, 1920

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1920-06-02

Civil actioN, tried before Bay, J., at November Term, 1919, of MacoN, upon the following issues: “1. Did the plaintiff deliver the trunk described in the complaint to the baggage agent of the defendant, Director General, at Charlotte, for the purpose of having same transported as baggage from Charlotte, N. C., to Cornelia, Georgia? Answer: ‘Yes.’ “2. Did tbe defendant, Director General, negligently fail to transport and deliver said trunk ? Answer: ‘Yes.’ “3.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1948

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1920-06-02

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Brown, J.

¶1 It is admitted tbat there is a limitation of liability to $100, but the plaintiff contends tbat under the act of Congress of 4 March, 1915, known as the Cummings Amendment, the plaintiff is entitled to recover the full amount of damages of $700. It appears tbat tbis statute was amended on 9 August, 1916, cb. 301, 39 Statute L, 441, as follows: “Provided, however, tbat the provisions hereof respecting liability for full actual loss, damage, or injury, notwithstanding any limitation of liability or recovery or representation, or agreement, or a lease as to value, and declaring any such limitation to be unlawful and void, shall not apply, first, to baggage carried on passenger trains or boats or trains, or boats carrying passengers,” etc., and in said amendment it is provided tbat the carrier might limit its liability by filing schedules with the Interstate Commerce Commission, as was done in tbis case.

¶2 We agree with tbe judge below tbat tbe act of Congress of 4 March, 1915, as amended, expressly exempts baggage from its provisions, requiring tbe payment of full actual damage in case of loss of baggage. Tbe limitation of liability of one hundred dollars contained in tbe tariff filed with Interstate Commerce Commission and duly approved by tbe Director General, in effect at tbe time of tbe loss of tbe baggage, governs tbis case and restricts tbe plaintiff’s recovery to $100.

¶3 Tbe judgment of tbe Superior Court for $100 is

¶4 Affirmed.

/179/nc/678 · .json · Public domain