Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

18 N.C. App. 478

State v. Odom

Court of Appeals of North Carolina · decided 1973-06-13

Relies on State v. McVay · 14 N.C. App. 468 - State v. Sneed

Decided 1973-06-13

HEDRICK,- Judge.

¶1Defendant contends the trial court erred in admitting into evidence witness Cole’s in-court identification of him as the perpetrator of the robbery.

¶2Before allowing Mrs. Cole’s in-court identification of defendant as the person who committed the robbery, the trial judge conducted a voir dire examination in the absence of the jury; and, after hearing testimony of Mrs. Cole, defendant, Deputy Sheriff Joe Warner of Richmond County, and Jesse Goodwin, Jailer of Richmond County, the court made findings and conclusions “[t]hat the identification or show-up of the defendant in the Richmound County Jail was unconstitutional and impermissible.” However, the judge made further findings that the in-court identification of defendant by Mrs. Cole was based “upon her independent memory in her viewing of him in her presence on August 25, 1972” and “was not tainted or rendered incompetent as evidence by the subsequent unconstitutional show-up at the Richmond County Jail.” Such findings when supported by competent evidence are conclusive on appellate courts, both State and Federal. State v. McVay and State v. Simmons, 279 N.C. 428, 183 S.E. 2d 652 (1971); State v. Sneed, 14 N.C. App. 468, 188 S.E. 2d 537 (1972). There is plenary, competent evidence in the record to support these positive findings. This assignment of error is overruled.

¶3Defendant assigns as error the denial of his motions for judgment as of nonsuit. There is plenary, competent evidence in the record to require submission of this case to the jury and to support the verdict.

¶4Defendant has additional assignments of error which we have carefully, considered and find to be. without merit.

¶5Defendant had a fair trial free from prejudicial error.

¶6No error.

Judges Bkock and VAUGHN concur.
/18/ncapp/478 · .json · Public domain