Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

18 N.H. 419

Kimball v. Pike

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided December 15, 1846

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1846-12-15

Debt, for rent on a lease. The plaintiff' offered in evidence an indenture of lease between Ezra Niles and the defendant, dated March 4, 1840, by which Niles leased to the defendant certain premises in Haverhill, and the defendant covenanted to pay a certain rent per year. The term of the lease was for live years, commencing March 9, 1840. The lease was assigned to the plaintiff’ by Niles, January 4, 1842.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1883

1 state decisions

Relies on Fitchburg Cotton Manufactory Corp. v. Melven · Keay v. Goodwin · Richard Scott v. Ezra

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1846-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Parker, C. J.

¶1The general principle is that rent reserved, and not due, is incident to the reversion, and passes with it to the assignee. 2 N. H. Rep. 454, York v. Jones; 16 Mass. 1, Keay v. Goodwin; 7 Pet. 596, Scott v. Lunt; 8 Cowen 206, 209, Demarest v. Willard; 3 Penrose & Watts (Penn.) 406, Johnson v. Smith. And the rule is the same where the assignment of the reversion is by mortgage instead of being by an absolute conveyance. Doug. 270, Moss v. Gallimore; 1 D. & E. 383, Birch v. Wright; 3 Met. 76, Burden v. Thayer; 15 Mass. 269, Fitchburg Man. Co. v. Melvin; 1 Vt. 457, Babcock v. Kennedy. Wheeler v. Branscombe, 5 Adolph. & Ellis. 373, appears to have been decided upon the special circumstances of the ease. Mr. Justice Coleridge said, “The documents show the intention of the parties not to have been to dispose of the reversion, but to make the mortgagee the agent or bailiff of the mortgagor, with authority to receive the rents.”

¶2Upon these authorities there could be no question in this case, had it not been for the assignment of the lease by the lessor. As against the rights of the lessor, who is also the mortgagor, the right of the mortgagee was complete at the time of the execution of the mortgage. 1 Met. 494, Welch v. Adams. There might have been a reservation of the rent. Co. Litt. 143.

¶3But it is very apparent that no subsequent assignment of the lease can take away this right of the mortgagee. The rule in relation to negotiable securities, transferred *421before they are payable, does not apply. 19 Pick. 476, Stone v. Patterson; 2 Hill 274, Willard v. Tillman.

¶4It may well be doubted whether, if the assignment of the lease had occurred before the making of the mortgage, it would have made any difference, there being no reservation of the rent in the mortgage, and no notice of the lease to the mortgagee.

¶5Verdict set aside.

/18/nh/419 · .json · Public domain