Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

18 Vt. 195

State v. Barker

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided January 15, 1846

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1846-01-15

<p>When an act is constituted an offence by statute, and there is an exception in the body of the statute, which enters into it as part of the description of the offence, the exception must be negatived in an indictment for committing the offence.</p> <p>In an indictment founded upon section 3, chap. 82, of the Revised Statutes, which prohibits, on the sabbath, the exercise of “ any secular labor, business, or employment, except such only as works of necessity and charity,” it must be alleged that the act, charged as an offence against the statute, was not a work of necessity, or charity.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“shall exercise any secular labor, business, or employment, except such only as works of necessity and charity, he shall be punished,”

quoted by 1 later decision, including United States v. Britton

Relies on State v. Butler

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1846-01-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 15 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently July 1994

1 federal appellate · 13 state decisions

401846185018601870188018901900191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Bennett, J.

¶2This case comes before the court upon exceptions taken on trial, and also upon exceptions to the decision of the county court in overruling the motion in arrest. The only question, with which the court have found any difficulty, relates to the sufficiency of the complaint; but as we are all agreed, that the complaint is bad, it is of no importance to pass upon any other questions in the case.

¶3The complaint charges the respondent with the exercise of secular business upon the sabbath, without negating that the business was a work of necessity, or charity. The rule of law is, that, "when the exception is in the body of the statute, which enacts the offence, and enters into it as a part of its description, it becomes necessary to state all the facts, which constitute the offence; and to do this, the exception in such case must be negatived. The authorities cited in argument fully sustain this position. If the exception is distinct from the enacting clause, it then becomes matter of defence, and it need not be negatived in the indictment, that the respondent is within the exception. State v. Butler, 17 Vt. 149. The reason why the rule is different in the two cases is quite obvious.

¶4The statute (Rev. St. 394) prohibits any one from exercising, on the sabbath, “ any secular labor, business or employment, except *198such only as works of necessity and charity." It is necessary, then, in order to constitute a violation of this statute, that the work complained of should not be a work of necessity, or charity ; and the effect is the same, as if the exception in the statute had been in this form, not being works of necessity and charity. It would then be quite apparent, that the latter words would qualify and explain what kind of labor, business and employment was prohibited.

¶5It has, it is true, been held, that an indictment for not going to church need not aver, that the respondent had no reasonable excuse for his absence, though the words of the statute are, “ haying no reasonable excuse.” 1 Chit. Cr. Law 283, 284. In such a case, if the respondent has a reasonable excuse, it is matter of exemption, and the respondent must avail himself of it, — that is, he must show that he comes within the exception. The fact, whether the respondent has a reasonable excuse, must be peculiarly within his own knowledge. The Massachusetts statute of 1791 provides, in the enacting part, that no innholder, &c., shall entertain any persons, not being travelers, strangers■, or lodgers on the Lord’s day, under a given penalty for each person entertained; and it was held, that the indictment must negative their being travelers, &c. Commonwealth v. Maxwell, 2 Pick. 139. This statute is in effect like the one, upon which the present complaint is grounded.

¶6The result is, the judgment of the county court is reversed and sentence arrested for insufficiency of the complaint.

/18/vt/195 · .json · Public domain