Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

180 Mass. 243

Fletcher v. Willis

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 2, 1902

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1902-01-02

<p>Agency, Scope of authority. Evidence, Inference from not calling witness.</p> <p>The acts of an agent or servant are not evidence of his authority.</p> <p>In an action for an assault committed by the defendant’s servant, where the only issue was whether the servant acted within the scope of his authority, the servant was present in court and identified but was not called as a witness by either the plaintiff or the defendant. The presiding judge refused to rule, that, in connection with the servant’s acts, the fact that the defendant did not call him to deny it was evidence of his authority, and left it wholly to the jury to say whether under the circumstances any inference should be drawn as to what the servant’s testimony on the point of his authority would have been. Held, that this was as much as the plaintiff was entitled to. The judge could not discriminate against the defendant for not doing what it was equally in the power of either party to do.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1902-01-02

How this case has been cited

Cited by 16 later decisions — most recently January 1968

1 federal appellate · 15 state decisions

801902191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Holmes, O. J.

¶1This is an action, for an assault and battery, admitted to have been unjustifiable, committed by the defen drant’s servant, upon the plaintiff. The case went to the jury on the single question whether the servant was acting within the scope of his authority. The scene of the assault was a race track, and the servant had been employed by the defendant about the track for a long time. The plaintiff contended and asked for a ruling that, in connection with his long employment and the fact that the defendant did not call him to deny it, the servant’s conduct was evidence of his authority. The judge refused the request and ruled that the servant’s acts were not evidence of his authority as against the defendant. The plaintiff excepted. The only exceptions are tq this refusal and ruling.

¶2The ruling of the judge was right. Brigham v. Peters, 1 Gray, 139. Mechem, Agency, § 100. That asked for the plaintiff might have been rejected properly enough even if it had not been wrong in point of law, as an attempt to gather details into an argument and then to put the argument into the mouth of the judge.

¶3The servant was present in court and stood up to be identified before the jury. Neither party saw fit to call him. The judge in adverting to the fact that the defendant did not put him on the stand, left it wholly to the jury to say whether under the circumstances any inference should be. drawn as to what his testimony on the point of his authority would have been. This was as much as the plaintiff was entitled to. The judge could not discriminate against the defendant for not doing what, so far as appears, was equally in the power of both parties to' do, and give to the' défendant’s. omission the effect of making the servant’s acts prove his authority, when otherwise they could not have that effect.

¶4 Exceptions overruled.

/180/mass/243 · .json · Public domain