Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

183 Ky. 434

Rammage v. Kendall

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided February 28, 1919

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1919-02-28

<p>Appeal and Error — Subsequent Appeal — Law of Case. — The facts being substantially the same, the opinion on a former appeal is the law of the case, and binding alike on the trial court and the Court of Appeals.</p>

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently March 1932

3 state decisions

Relies on Rammage v. Kendall · Carter Coal Co. v. Dozier

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1919-02-28

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion of the Court by

William: Rogers Clay, Commissioner

¶2Revérsing.

¶3This is the second appeal of this case. The opinion on the former appeal may be found in 168 Ky. 26, 181 S. W. 631, where the facts are fully set out. The suit was brought by Rammage against Kendall for false imprisonment. ¿Qn the first trial, there was a judgment for Kendall. On appeal, we held that Kendall, as judge of the county court, was without jurisdiction to try Rammage, and reversed the judgment with directions to give a peremptory instruction in favor of the plaintiff, if upon another trial the facts were substantially the same. On the return of the case, another trial was had and a peremptory instruction given in favor of the defendant. Plaintiff again appeals.

¶4We have carefully examined the evidence on the last trial, and so far as the jurisdictional facts are concerned, it is substantially the same as that heard on the first ■trial. That being true, the opinion on the former appeal is the law of the case, and binding alike on the trial court and this court. Carter Coal Co. v. Dozier, 179 Ky. 457, 200 S. W. 917. It follows that the trial court should have directed a verdict for plaintiff instead of defendant.

¶5Judgment reversed and cause remanded for a new trial consistent with this opinion.

/183/ky/434 · .json · Public domain