Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

183 Misc. 626

Atkinson v. Vulcan Corp.

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 23, 1944

New York Supreme Court · decided 1944-08-23

Relies on Bluebird Undergarment Corp. v. Gomez

Decided 1944-08-23

Peck, J.

¶1This is a motion by the plaintiff, pursuant to an attachment, to compel a third party to deliver a corrected certificate to the sheriff, showing an indebtedness to the defendant. The certificate furnished [Civ. Prae. Act, § 918] denied any indebtedness. Plaintiff examined the third party under section 919 of the Civil Practice Act and claims that the examination establishes an indebtedness. Upon that showing plaintiff moves to compel the third party to correct his certificate. The third party still denies any indebtedness and challenges the authority of the court to issue the requested order.

¶2There is no statutory provision authorizing the court to order a person who has been examined under section 919, because the certificate furnished by him was suspected to be untrue or deemed inadequate, to furnish the sheriff with a corrected certificate (see 7 Carmody on New York Pleading and Practice, p. 566; Buckingham v. White, 25 Hun 441). The City Court decision in Bluebeard Undergarment Corporation v. Gomez (139 Misc. 742) relied upon by the plaintiff, turned upon another point and the question now before the court is not discussed. The procedure for contesting the certificate and asserting plaintiff’s claim is by a sheriff’s action, under section 922 of the Civil Practice Act, not by summary motion.

¶3Motion denied.

/183/misc/626 · .json · Public domain