Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

188 Ky. 533

Vallandingham v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided June 18, 1920

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1920-06-18

<p>iSedncttonr — Seduction Under Promise of Marriage — Evidence.—• In a prosecution for seduction under promise of marriage, it is fprejwdiml error to permit the prosecuting witness either in substance or effect to testify that as a result of the illicit re* lations a child was horn.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently January 1932

1 state decisions

Relies on Jordan v. Commonwealth · Hoskins v. Commonwealth · Cline v. Commonwealth

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1920-06-18

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion op the Court by

Chiep Justice Carroll

¶2Bever sing.

¶3The appellant, Yallandingham, was found guilty of seducing Grace Purvis under a promise of marriage and from the judgment on the verdict' he appeals.

¶4The only witnesses who testified as to any material fact in the case were Grace Purvis, the prosecuting witness, who was about 20 years of age, and the accused, a young man of 22. She testified that Yallandingham accomplished heir’ seduction after he had promised to marry her; while he denied that he had promised to marry or had sexual intercourse with the accused.

¶5On the trial the prosecuting witness was asked and answered over the objection of counsel for defendant these questions: “Q. Did you ever have any sexual relations with him? A. Yes, sir. Q. How long after the first time that you had sexual relations with him was it before your baby was born? A. It was seven or eight months or something that way. Q. Up to the time that you had sexual relations with him had any other man had sexual knowledge of you? A. No, sir.”

¶6Arid it is now .insisted that the court _ committed prejudicial error in permitting these questions to be asked ,and- answers made.

¶7In the case of Jordan v. Commonwealth, 180 Ky. 379, we had the competency of evidence of this nature before us and held that it was incompetent and prejudicial. To the same effect is Cline v. Commonwealth, 186 Ky. 429; Hoskins v. Commonwealth, 188 Ky. 80. The evidence here introduced is substantially the same as that held inadmissible and prejudicial in the Jordan case.

¶8It is also complained that the attorney for the Commonwealth in his closing argument was guilty of misconduct in referring to this incompetent evidence. The court, however, admonished the jury not to regard it, *535and as this error will not again occur, nothing more need he said about it. .

¶9For the error mentioned, the judgment is reversed, with directions for a new trial not inconsistent with this opinion.

/188/ky/533 · .json · Public domain