Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

19 Ala. 13

State v. Davis

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided January 15, 1851

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1851-01-15

UpoN points reserved as novel and difficult, from the City Court of Mobile. Tried before the Hon. ’Alex. MeKinstry. James Davis and George Ferguson were indicted in the City Court of Mobile, for obtaining money under false pretences from one Dr. M. Parker, who was examined on the trial, as a witness for the State.

Decided 1851-01-15

PARSONS, J.

¶1The counsel of the prisoners relies upon Rex v. Davis and another, 25 Eng. Comm. L. Rep. 341, to show that the evidence should have been excluded. But that case does not show that it should have been excluded as matter of legal right, and we certainly can not go that length. The two indictments were for different and distinct crimes; and in the other case these prisoners were indicted and tried jointly with another person. The evidence of the crime in this case was no.t given on the trial of that, to prove the crime, hut only to connect the parties in a common design and confederacy. These prisoners were not convicted of this crime upon that indictment, though the evidence of this crime may have contributed to connect the parties in the commission of that. Whether for such a purpose it was admissible, was a question to he settled in that case, hut not in this. This is the only question which the court below referred to this court.

¶2The judgment is affirmed.

/19/ala/13 · .json · Public domain