Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

19 Haw. 564

Kane v. Medeiros

Hawaii Supreme Court

Decided October 11, 1909

Hawaii Supreme Court · decided 1909-10-11

<p>Guardian and ward — promise to pay ward’s debts.</p> <p>A guardian’s promise to pay ward’s debts, incurred prior to his appointment, being without consideration, is not actionable.</p>

Decided 1909-10-11

¶1OPINION OP THE COURT BY

HARTWELL, C.J.

¶2The plaintiff was nonsuited upon a showing made by his evidence that he had furnished board and lodging to the minors prior to the appointment of the defendant as guardian and that after the appointment the defendant promised to pay the plaintiff therefor, the complaint alleging that the “defendant is indebted to the plaintiff in the sum of forty-two dollars for boarding and lodging said minors,” and that “in consideration whereof said defendant promised to pay said sum to plaintiff.” But the defendant was not indebted as alleged; it was the minors, if any one, who were indebted for necessaries. The action therefore does not lie against the guardian since the evidence shows there is no legal consideration for his promise.

¶3If the debt is due from the minors and their estate should justify the’ guardian in making the payment and he should make it his accounts would undoubtedly be allowed in probate. The statute requires the guardian to “pay all just debts due from the ward out of his personal estate, if sufficient, and if not, out of his real estate, upon obtaining a license for the sale thereof, as hereinafter provided.” Sec, 2313 R. L. But the *565remedy for his failure to do this would not be an action against him in the present form.

W. O. A chi for plaintiff.O. IT. Olson (Holmes, Stanley & Olson on the brief) for defendant.

¶4Exception to nonsuit overruled.

/19/haw/564 · .json · Public domain