Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

19 Johns. 279

Dickenson v. Rogers & Richards

New York Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1822

New York Supreme Court · decided 1822-01-15

THIS was an action of assault and battery and false imprisonment, tried at the Warren circuit, in June, 1820, before Mr. Justice Platt. It was proved that the defendants, on the 9th of December, 1818, entered the plaintiff’s shop, in Caldwell, in Warren county, and arrested the plaintiff, locked him up in the gaol of that county for the night, and on the next day took him to Troy, before the Recorder of that city.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently April 1949

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1822-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Spencer, Ch. J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court. If tjje warrant issued by the Recorder of Troy was a legal process,'then, it is conceded, the defendant was entitled *° a verd>ct. The objection is, that the warrant was not in the name of the people of the state of New- York /-and it was urged, on the argument, that the constitution was imperative in this particular, and that, therefore, the warrant was void. The constitution ordains, “ that all writs and other proceedings shall run in the name of the People of the state of New-York, and be tested in the name of the Chancellor or chief Judge of the Court from whence they issue.” This provision obviously extends only to the Court of Chancery, and Courts of Record having common law jurisdiction. The provision was meant to be co-éxtensive with the usage and practice of similar courts in England. The Recorder of Troy, having the powers of a judge or the Supreme Court in vacation, acted as a justice of the peáce in issuing.this warrant. It was a ministerial act, not one of a judicial character. It was issued by a magistrate as conservator of the peace, and not as the act of a court. It is perfectly well settled in England, that a warrant may be either in the king’s name, or in the name of the justice himself; and the latter is the most usual. (Hawk. b. 2. ch. 13. s. 24. 2 Hale, 113. 1 Chitty's C. L. 32.)

¶2The words of the constitution do not require the construction contended for; and it cannot be believed that, with respect to justices’ warrants, it was meant to innovate upon the law of the land.

¶3Judgment for the defendants.

/19/johns/279 · .json · Public domain