Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

19 Johns. 305

Hawkins v. Stark

New York Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1822

New York Supreme Court · decided 1822-01-15

ASSUMPSIT for money had and received to the use of the plaintiff. Plea, non assumpsit, with notice of special matter to be given in evidence at the trial. • The cause was tried at the Albany circuit, in October, 1820, before Mr. Justice Woodworth. John Bishop testified, that he purchased oxen of the plaintiff, and Morris Softer, belonging to the society of Mew Lebanon Shakers, and gave the plaintiff his note for 250 dollars.

Decided 1822-01-15

Platt, J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court. When the plaintiff received the doubloons, in part payment of the note, they were undoubtedly his money. But after he returned them to Bishop, from whom he received them, and Bishop bad agreed to take them back, the property of the plaintiff in those gold pieces was transferred to B., and the payment on the note was virtually rescinded. By sending the doubloons back, the plaintiff elected not to consider them as his money. By accepting, them when returned, B. made them his own, and virtually agreed to stand indebted to the plaintiff, as though no doubloons had been passed between them. B. had, then, a right to dispose of the gold as he pleased. It was his own money. And the plaintiff had a right of action against him for the whole amount of the note. There appears to be no privity, nor contract, express or implied, between the defendant and the plaintiff. B. re-delivered the doubloons to the defendant from whom he received them. They then became the property of the defendant, who was accountable for their value, to B., not to the plaintiff. The action has been misconceived The verdict must, therefore, be set aside, and a new trial granted, with costs to abide the event of the suit.

¶2New trial granted.

/19/johns/305 · .json · Public domain