Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

19 Misc. 2d 555

Clarke v. Sharp Trading Corp.

New York Supreme Court

Decided November 4, 1959

New York Supreme Court · decided 1959-11-04

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1969

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1959-11-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mario Pittoni, J.

¶1Motion for a preference is denied.

¶2The cause of action arises out of the plaintiff’s fall caused by tripping over a defective carpet runner in a hotel.

¶3The plaintiff, a woman 40 years of age, was- suffering from a heart condition prior to the fall. The physician’s affidavit says that this “ previous heart abnormality was aggravated by the fall ”; and also that she may not be alive in the event that this case should proceed to trial at a later date ”. Thus he does not say affirmatively that the plaintiff is in imminent danger of death in the near future. It has been held that ‘ ‘ There must be an unreserved and unequivocal affidavit by a physician and the opinion of the physician must be supported by credible medical facts ”. (Dodumoff v. Lyons, 4 A D 2d 626, 627 [1st Dept.].) And further, There is no persuasive showing of probability of death before trial in the regular order; and the granting of the motion was an improvident exercise of discretion”. [O’Callaghan v. Brawley, 276 App. Div. 908 [2d Dept.].)

¶4Therefore, the plaintiff has failed to establish facts entitling her to a preference.

¶5Motion denied.

/19/misc2d/555 · .json · Public domain