¶1delivered the opinion of the court.
¶2The defendants, Henry and Eliza Treseler, were husband and wife prior to April 28, 1884, when they were divorced. In January, 1883, Henry Treseler borrowed two hundred dollars from the plaintiff, giving his note at nine months for repayment. In May, 1883, Treseler desired to convey his homestead property on Twenty-sixth street and Cass avenue to one Klostermann, for $7,500, but his wife refused to join in the conveyance, until he agreed to transfer for her sole benefit a certain other lot on Cass avenue, together with one on O’Fallon street, and also to pay her $2,000 from the proceeds of the sale'to Klostenmmn. There was an incumbrance of
¶3We think the decree was right. The force of the arguments against it may be condensed into the proposition that the conveyance of all the lots through Mrs. Noltman to Mrs. Treseler was an entire and indivisible transfer, for the single consideration of Mrs. Treseler’s release of dower in the homestead property, and it is error, therefore, to, separate the Taylor avenue lots from the others, in identifying a valuable and sufficient consideration for the entire property. Waiving the question whether, under all the circumstances of the case, there was a valid conveyance of any of the property against existing cred*522itors, it is perfectly clear that thus to lump the whole transaction and declare its elements inseparable, would be to adjudicate upon the semblance, instead of the reality. Looking only on the surface, we find Mrs. Treseler, on the one hand, releasing her dower contrary to her inclinations, and on the other, Treseler compensating her with a transfer of property, including the Taylor avenue lots. But beneath this we see it plainly established by all the testimony, that Mrs. Treseler never demanded, expected, or received these lots as having any connection with the agreed consideration for her sacrifice. They came to her without solicitation, stipulation, or purchase in any way. It is true, that all previous negotiations are generally merged in the act of consummation. But here, the element of gratuity did not cease to be present in the consummation itself. The lots were a free gift from Treseler, and nothing else. Courts must in such cases act upon things, and not upon appearances, which differ from the things done. There is a suggestion that these lots were substituted for the $2,000 which the husband, failed to pay. But not a line in the record intimates that such an idea was ever thought of by any of the parties concerned. The subsequent payment of two hundred dollars by Treseler to his wife, certainly does not confirm any suspicion that the money obligation had been already compounded and settled.
¶4It is pretty well settled in this state that a convey-anee without consideration will not be upheld against an existing creditor who afterwards finds it impossible to obtain satisfaction of his demand without resorting to the property so conveyed. Potter v. McDowell, 31 Mo. 62 ; Pawley v. Vogel, 42 Mo. 291; Hurley v. Taylor, 78 Mo. 238.
¶5The rule well fits the facts in the present case, and the circuit court made a justly discriminating application of it to the conveyance of the Taylor avenue lots.
¶6The judgment is affirmed,