¶1
¶2*89
¶3*90
¶4For the sole error pointed out the judgment is reversed, and the cause remanded for a new trial.
¶5Reversed and remanded.
191 Ala. 87
Decided January 14, 1915
Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1915-01-14
<p> Probate of Will. </p> <p>1. Wills; Contest; Undue Influence. — Where the issue of undue influence was raised in a will contest, a charge that the paper propounded for probate could not be found to be the result of undue influence unless the jury was satisfied by a preponderance of the evidence that it was not such a will as the testator desired to make, exacted a too high degree of proof, and was erroneous.</p> <p>2. Same; Alternate Instruction. — The charge that the paper propounded for probate could not be found to be the result of undue influence unless the jury was satisfied that it was not such a will as the testator desired to make, and that it was procured by coercion or fraud, being in the disjunctive, signified that the conception of coercion and of fraud were substantially equivalent, and hence, the charge was not positively erroneous.</p> <p>3. Same; Validity; Undue Influence. — Where a will is the result of a moral, social or domestic force exerted upon a party, overcoming the free action of his will, or controlling the same, and preventing any true expression of intent, the courts will relieve against it on the ground of undue influence, which is equivalent to coercion or fraud, and must have an effect upon the mind of the testator, equivalent to that of coercion or fraud — in short must destroy its freedom of choice and action; such coercion need not be physical duress, but may be moral only, and such fraud need not be actual, but may be constructive.</p> <p>4. Charge of Court; Misleading; Explanatory. — Where a charge is merely misleading, and not positively erroneous, the duty is on the party against whom it is given to request explanatory instructions, else he cannot complain.</p> <p>5. Witnesses; Examination; Will Contest. — In contests of wills a wide latitude is allowed to parties in the cross-examination of witnesses, such matter resting largely within the discretion of the trial court.</p>
Relies on Councill v. Mayhew · Moore v. Heineke · Torrey v. Burney
Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know
Reversed and remanded · Decided 1915-01-14
Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently February 1938
9 state decisions
Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.
View the full empirical analysis of this case →
¶1
¶2*89
¶3*90
¶4For the sole error pointed out the judgment is reversed, and the cause remanded for a new trial.
¶5Reversed and remanded.