Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

195 Misc. 839

Moczydlowski v. Westall

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 24, 1949

New York Supreme Court · decided 1949-08-24

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently August 1949

1 state decisions

Relies on Kerns v. Whiting · Matter of Miraglia v. Cohen

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1949-08-24

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Schmidt, J.

¶1Here the petitioner seeks to validate his petitions for the Democratic nomination for councilman from the Fifth Ward of the City of Yonkers.

¶2It is conceded that when the petitions were signed they used the term “ Alderman ” in describing the office for which they wished to nominate the petitioner and that the petitions were in this form when validated before a notary public. All acknowl*840edgments were by subscribing witnesses. After such validation it is further conceded that the word “ Alderman ” where it occurred was crossed out and the word “ Councilman ” substituted therefor.

¶3This is shown by the following portion of the stipulation put on the record at the hearing by the attorney for the petitioner.

¶4“We will concede that the change on the petition at the top changing the word Alderman to Councilman was put there after the signatures were signed by the Notary Public who witnessed it and who initialed it and put her initials at the top. ”

¶5The petitioner argues rather persuasively that the signers knew that they were expressing their preference for their representation in the city council by whatever term the office was designated.

¶6We find no authority directly in point but hold that it would be a dangerous practice and one open to abuse to sustain a petition on which, admittedly a substantial alteration is made not only after the signatures had been affixed but also after the subscribing witnesses, who were' the ones who had seen the signers sign, had acknowledged the instruments before a notary public and thus validated them. This alteration was made by the notary public whose only function with respect to the petition was to take the acknowledgment of the subscribing witness.

¶7The numerous authorities submitted by the parties have been examined and while none is exactly in point it appears to be the law that a petition is rendered invalid by alterations made after authentication. (Matter of Miraglia v. Cohen, 282 N. Y. 739; Matter of Kerns v. Whiting, 187 Misc. 656.)

¶8The motion to validate is accordingly denied.

¶9Submit order.

/195/misc/839 · .json · Public domain