Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

198 Ala. 118

Holloway v. Smith

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided July 16, 1916

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1916-07-16

Heard before Hon. Gaston Gunter. Bill by Mary J. Smith against J. Lee Holloway, to charge a •certain lot of land with a lien for an amount necessary for the •erection of a suitable residence for a family such as Holloway has, or to vacate and set aside a conveyance of the lot to Holloway. From a decree overruling demurrers to the bill, respondent appeals.

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently May 1932

5 state decisions

Relies on Patton v. Beecher · Brock v. Brock · Tillman v. Kifer

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed and remanded · Decided 1916-07-16

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCLELLAN, J.

¶1If we accept this bill’s averments as justifying the theory upon which complainant (appellee) would rest her claim for favorable consideration in a court of equity — an acceptance that is not justified by the allegations of fact made— *119this is the substance of the cause of complaint and the basis for the rescission sought: The grantor conveyed a lot to the grantee-upon consideration of a parol promise by the grantee that he would construct upon the land a dwelling for himself, the grantee failed or refused to make the improvement, and the grantor would have the contract (including, of course, the conveyance) rescinded. Among other objections not now necessary to be-noted, the demurrer pointed this one: “That the bill seeks to-enforce an illegal parol agreement which is void under the statute of frauds.” This ground of demurrer was well taken, according-to the. apt authority of Patton v. Beecher, 62 Ala. 579, Brock v. Brock, 90 Ala. 86, 8 South. 11, 9 L. R. A. 287, and Tillman v. Kifer, 166 Ala. 403, 405, 52 South. 309, among others. The failure or refusal to perform a parol promise is not a fraud efficient to relieve the transaction of the effect of the statute of frauds.— Authorities supra. There is no averment of fraud in the bill.

¶2The demurrer was erroneously overruled. The decree is-reversed, and the cause is remanded.

¶3Reversed and remanded.

Anderson, C. J., and Gardner and Thomas, JJ., concur.
/198/ala/118 · .json · Public domain