Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

199 Ill. App. 474

Pacific Express Co. v. Spaulding & Co.

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided May 29, 1915

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1915-05-29

<p>Abstract of the Decision.</p> <p>1. Carriers, § 182*—when evidence of knowledge of existence of provision in receipt limiting liability to certain sum admissible in action against shipper for fraud. In an action by a carrier, based on fraud and deceit of a shipper in delivering to it for shipment goods of a value greater than $50 without stating the value thereof, to recover damages sustained by the recovery of a judgment against it by the consignee for loss of the shipment, evidence of knowledge by the shipper’s shipping clerk that the receipt for the shipment contained a provision limiting the carrier’s liability to $50, unless the true value exceeding that amount be stated, is admissible.</p> <p>2. Carriers, § 134*—who may sue for loss of goods in transit. On delivery to a carrier of a shipment purchased by the consignee he becomes the owner thereof, and alone can recover for loss in transit caused by carrier’s negligence.</p> <p>3. Carriers, § 172*—when consignee not bound by restrictions in bill of lading. Without authority from the consignee to do so, the consignor cannot bind the consignee by restrictions in the bill of lading.</p> <p>4. Carriers, § 168*—what does not constitute actionable fraud or deceit by consignor. Delivery of shipment to carrier by consignor, without stating the value thereof, though he knows there is a clause in the receipt limiting carrier’s liability to $50 in case a higher value is not given, does not amount to fraud and deceit entitling the carrier to recover damages sustained by recovery of a judgment against it by the consignee for loss of shipment.</p> <p>5. Judgment, § 502*—when judgment by consignee against carrier for negligence conclusive in action by carrier against consignor. Where a consignee has recovered judgment against a carrier for loss of shipment caused by the latter’s negligence, such carrier cannot recover damages sustained thereby of the consignor based on his fraud and deceit in not stating the true value of the shipment under contract limiting carrier’s liability to a certain amount unless such shipment is valued in excess thereof.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1940

1 federal appellate ·

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed · Decided 1915-05-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Presiding Justice McSurely

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

4. Carriers, § 168*—what does not constitute actionable fraud or deceit by consignor. Delivery of shipment to carrier by consignor, without stating the value thereof, though he knows there is a clause in the receipt limiting carrier’s liability to $50 in case a higher value is not given, does not amount to fraud and deceit entitling the carrier to recover damages sustained by recovery of a judgment against it by the consignee for loss of shipment.5. Judgment, § 502*—when judgment by consignee against carrier for negligence conclusive in action by carrier against consignor. Where a consignee has recovered judgment against a carrier for loss of shipment caused by the latter’s negligence, such carrier cannot recover damages sustained thereby of the consignor based on his fraud and deceit in not stating the true value of the shipment under contract limiting carrier’s liability to a certain amount unless such shipment is valued in excess thereof.
/199/illapp/474 · .json · Public domain