Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1997 Ohio 145

State ex rel. Moore v. Indus. Comm.

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided August 6, 1997

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 1997-08-06

Workers' compensation—Violation of a specific safety requirement—Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A)—Industrial Commission does not abuse its discretion in finding that a hopper bin does not constitute a "confined space," when.

Relies on State ex rel. Burton v. Industrial Commission · State ex rel. Jeep Corp. v. Industrial Commission · State ex rel. Moore v. Industrial Commission

Decided 1997-08-06

[This opinion has been published in Ohio Official Reports at 
79 Ohio St.3d 347
.]




   THE STATE EX REL. MOORE, APPELLANT, V. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION OF
                               OHIO ET AL., APPELLEES.
            [Cite as State ex rel. Moore v. Indus. Comm., 
1997-Ohio-145
.]
Workers’ compensation—Violation of a specific safety requirement—Ohio
           Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A)—Industrial Commission does not abuse its
           discretion in finding that a hopper bin does not constitute a “confined
           space,” when.
           (No. 95-501—Submitted May 20, 1997—Decided August 6, 1997.)
    APPEAL from the Court of Appeals for Franklin County, No. 94APD01-19.
                                  __________________
           {¶ 1} Appellee Midwest Elastomers, Inc. engages in rubber reprocessing.
Through a cryogenic process, rubber is frozen and then pulverized. One of the
procedures involved was referred to as the “X-process.” Raw rubber material was
first dumped into one of six hoppers. The hopper bin in question was six feet wide,
eight feet deep, and, at its lowest point, six feet above the floor. The bin was six
feet across on the top and completely open. The sides of the bin initially descended
straight down and then sloped into a V. A ladder extended fourteen feet from the
floor to the top of the bin.
           {¶ 2} At the hopper’s bottom was an auger with a protective covering. The
auger pulled the rubber pieces into a bucket elevator, which transported the material
to a freezing chamber. There, liquid nitrogen was sprayed on the rubber, which
caused it to become brittle. The brittle rubber then dropped into a hammer mill,
which crushed the material. The rubber then moved through a six-inch pipe to a
sifter-like machine called a “Sweco,” which separated recoverable material from
rejects.
                              SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




         {¶ 3} Integral to the entire process was the liquid nitrogen. In the course of
the freezing process, the nitrogen expanded into a gas. The gas ultimately traveled
through the enclosed system to the Sweco, where it was either recycled into the
freezing chamber or vented harmlessly into the plant.
         {¶ 4} Each day before the X-process was begun, vent lines were cleaned.
The parties agree that on the morning of October 16, 1990, the vents had been
cleaned. Later that day, for reasons unknown, a Midwest employee, Gregory C.
Moore, climbed into the hopper. Unbeknownst to Moore, or any other Midwest
employee, the two Sweco vents had become blocked with rubber material. This
caused the nitrogen gas to back up into the hopper, overcoming Moore. A fellow
employee, Marshall O. Russell, Jr., noticed Moore’s forklift by the hopper, but
could not find Moore. Investigating, Russell found Moore in the hopper and
attempted to rescue him, but was also overcome. Other employees, alerted to the
situation, quickly removed the two men. Russell was successfully revived. Moore
was not.
         {¶ 5} Widow-claimant Lisa L. Moore, appellant herein, filed a workers’
compensation death claim with appellee Industrial Commission of Ohio.
Following allowance of that claim, she filed an application for additional
compensation, alleging violations of several specific safety requirements
(“VSSR”). She later withdrew the claimed violations of Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-
5-22(D) and 4121:1-5-02(D)(1).
         {¶ 6} After investigation and transcribed hearing, the commission denied
claimant’s application, writing in part:
         “It is the finding of the Hearing Officer that the Application for Violation
of a Specific Safety Requirement be denied for the reason that the widow-claimant
has cited no specific safety requirement which was violated resulting in decedent’s
death.




                                           2
                                January Term, 1997




       “The findings and order are based on the V.S.S.R. Investigation Report,
affidavits, photographs, evidence in file and evidence adduced at hearing.
       “In this case the decedent, a material handler, died on October 16, 1990
because of asphyxiation. The asphyxiation occurred while decedent was inside a
feedstock hopper.
       “… [T]he only rules under consideration are [Ohio Adm.Code] 4121:1-
5-22(A)(1) [and] (2) [and] (C); 4121:1-5-17(F)(1); and 4121:1-5-18(C)(2)[,] (3)
[and] (4).
       “Before reviewing the merits of the cited rules[,] a brief explanation is stated
herein outlining how the feed hopper and related processes work.
       “The employer is involved in a rubber re-processing operation. There are
various feed hoppers used throughout the plant. Raw rubber materials are put into
these hoppers. An auger moves the raw material to a bucket elevator and the bucket
elevator takes the product over to a freezing chamber. The products are then
separated into groups that meet the required specifications and those that do not
meet the specifications are rejected.
       “Involved in this process is nitrogen that is piped from the outside through
underground pipes to the factory. The nitrogen is brought into valves that inject
the nitrogen with the rubber product to keep it cold. The liquid nitrogen then
becomes gaseous and vents into the plant. It was estimated that the liquid nitrogen
is injected approximately 15 to 20 feet from where the hopper is located.
       “Apparently in this case the pipelines carrying the nitrogen became plugged
and the nitrogen gas was not vented normally and backed up into the hopper
overcoming the decedent. It should be emphasized that the mixing of the nitrogen
with the rubber is entirely a closed process.
       “Rule 4121:1-5-22 states that: ‘(A) No employee shall be required to enter
into any confined space unless the confined space entry procedure, incorporating
one of the following, is used (see appendix to this rule for recommended entry




                                          3
                             SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




procedures): (1) Air sampling shall be performed by qualified, trained personnel
prior to and periodically during occupancy to determine that the atmosphere within
the confined space contains an adequate quantity of oxygen ([nineteen] per cent),
and any known or expected harmful atmospheric contaminants have been diluted
to safe concentrations. (2) [A supplied-air] respirator or a self-contained breathing
apparatus is provided and used. […] (C) Appropriate control measures, which
may consist of forced or natural ventilation, use of personal protective equipment,
a combination of these[,] or other effective control techniques, shall be instituted if
tests under [p]aragraph (A)(1) or (B) of this rule indicate that the atmosphere in the
space to be entered contains: (1) [A]ny concentration of flammable vapor or gas
[ten per cent] or greater of the lower explosive limit; and/or (2) [A] hazardous
concentration of any known or expected toxic contaminants; and/or (3) [L]ess than
nineteen per cent oxygen.’
       “Before reviewing the merits of this rule it is necessary to determine if the
hopper in question would qualify as a confined space under the rules. 4121:1-5-
01(B)(28) defines confined space as: ‘an enclosure not intended for continuous
employee occupancy, having limited means of ingress and egress and poor natural
ventilation and which may contain hazardous contaminants or be oxygen deficient.’
The hopper in question is concluded not to fall within this definition of a confined
space. Specifically, there is no record prior to this incident of the hopper ever
containing nitrogen gas, which is a hazardous contaminant. George Everage, a
company foreman for the employer, stated that for a period of at least eight years
prior to this incident [no one] in the plant [was] aware that nitrogen gas could get
into the feed hopper.
       “Therefore, because the rule implicitly requires that the employer be aware
that this area may contain a hazardous contaminant, and here the employer had no
way of knowing that the hopper could contain the hazardous contaminant nitrogen
gas[,] the hopper does not meet the definition of a confined space.



                                          4
                                January Term, 1997




       “Also, the hopper would not have poor ventilation as the rule required
because the hopper was open at the top approximately six feet and therefore there
was natural ventilation.
       “Therefore, because the hopper does not meet the definitional requirements
of a confined space as explained previously, none of the subsections under Rule
4121:1-5-22 apply and no violation of that rule is found. …”
       {¶ 7} The commission also found no violation of the rest of the cited
specific safety requirements.
       {¶ 8} Claimant sought reconsideration as to the finding of no violation of
Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A) only. Reconsideration was denied as follows:
       “Second, widow/claimant contends [that] the finding of the Deputy that the
feedstock hopper in which decedent died was not a ‘confined space’ for purposes
of OAC 4121:1-5-01(B)(28) is an obvious mistake of fact. The basis for the finding
contained in the order, that the hopper was open at the top, is not contested by
widow/claimant. Rather, widow/claimant contends that the fact of decedent’s death
demonstrates the inadequacy of the ventilation created by the opening of the hopper
at the top, at least insofar as it applies to the presence of nitrogen. The term used
in the applicable rule is ‘poor natural ventilation.’ Without a quantified standard,
the application of the fact of an open-top hopper to the term ‘poor natural
ventilation’ is a mixed question of law and fact. OAC 4121-3-20(G) does not
provide for rehearing unless the argued mistake is both one of fact (and not of law)
and obvious.
       “Third, widow/claimant contends [that] the conclusion contained in the
Deputy’s order that, to qualify as a ‘confined space’ the employer must be aware
[that] the area may contain a hazardous contaminant is an obvious mistake of fact.
This is solely a question of applicable law and as such no rehearing is provided for
under OAC 4121-3-20(G).”




                                         5
                             SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




       {¶ 9} Claimant filed a complaint in mandamus in the Court of Appeals for
Franklin County, alleging that the commission abused its discretion in finding no
violation of Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A). The court held that the commission
did not abuse its discretion in finding that the hopper bin did not constitute a
“confined space.”     It accordingly upheld the determination of this rule’s
inapplicability and denied the writ.
       {¶ 10} This cause is now before this court upon an appeal as of right.
                              ___________________
       Siferd & Reed, L.P.A., Richard E. Siferd and Victoria U. Maisch, for
appellant.
       Betty D. Montgomery, Attorney General, and Dennis L. Hufstader,
Assistant Attorney General, for appellee Industrial Commission of Ohio.
       Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease and Robert E. Tait, for appellee Midwest
Elastomers, Inc.
                              ___________________
       Per Curiam.
       {¶ 11} Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A) reads:
       “Confined spaces
       “(A) No employee shall be required to enter into any confined space unless
a confined space entry procedure, incorporating one of the following, is used (see
appendix to this rule for recommended entry procedures):
       “(1) Air sampling shall be performed by qualified, trained personnel prior
to and periodically during occupancy to determine that the atmosphere within the
confined space contains an adequate quantity of oxygen (nineteen per cent), and
any known or expected harmful atmospheric contaminants have been diluted to safe
concentrations.
       “(2) A supplied-air respirator or self-contained breathing apparatus is
provided and used.”



                                        6
                                January Term, 1997




       {¶ 12} Neither of these procedures was followed. At issue is whether they
needed to be. The commission and court of appeals answered this question in the
negative. Both found that the hopper bin was not a “confined space,” rendering
Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A) inapplicable. We agree.
       {¶ 13} The interpretation of a specific safety requirement rests with the
commission. State ex rel. Jeep Corp. v. Indus. Comm. (1989), 
42 Ohio St.3d 83
,
537 N.E.2d 215
. Because it is a penalty against the employer, “it must be strictly
construed, and all reasonable doubts concerning the interpretation of the safety
standard are to be construed against its applicability to the employer.” State ex rel.
Burton v. Indus. Comm. (1989), 
46 Ohio St.3d 170, 172
, 
545 N.E.2d 1216, 1219
.
Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-01(B)(28) defines a “confined space” as “an enclosure
not intended for continuous employee occupancy, having limited means of ingress
and egress and poor natural ventilation and which may contain hazardous
contaminants or be oxygen deficient.”
       {¶ 14} In this case, there is “some evidence”—indeed all the evidence
establishes—that the hopper was completely open on the top. This large opening,
in the commission’s view, provided sufficient natural ventilation to remove the
machine from the ambit of Ohio Adm.Code 4121:1-5-01(B)(28). This finding was
within the commission’s discretion and is, alone, sufficient to render Ohio
Adm.Code 4121:1-5-22(A) inapplicable.
       {¶ 15} The judgment of the court of appeals is affirmed.
                                                                 Judgment affirmed.
       MOYER, C.J., DOUGLAS, RESNICK, F.E. SWEENEY, PFEIFER, COOK and
LUNDBERG STRATTON, JJ., concur.
                               __________________




                                          7

/1997/ohio/145 · .json · Public domain