Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

1997 Ohio 257

Marshall v. Lazaroff

Ohio Supreme Court

Decided February 19, 1997

Ohio Supreme Court · decided 1997-02-19

Habeas corpus not available to challenge either the validity or sufficiency of an indictment—Allegations of fraud on part of prosecution relating to an indictment are not cognizable in habeas corpus—When petitioner is incarcerated for several crimes, sentencing court's lack of jurisdiction to sentence him on one of the crimes does not warrant release in habeas corpus.

Relies on State ex rel. Wilcox v. Seidner · 70 Ohio St. 3d 561 - Luna v. Russell · Swiger v. Seidner

Decided 1997-02-19

[This opinion has been published in Ohio Official Reports at 
77 Ohio St.3d 443
.]




          MARSHALL, APPELLANT, v. LAZAROFF, WARDEN, APPELLEE.
                   [Cite as Marshall v. Lazaroff, 
1997-Ohio-257
.]
Habeas corpus not available to challenge either the validity or sufficiency of an
        indictment—Allegations of fraud on part of prosecution relating to an
        indictment are not cognizable in habeas corpus—When petitioner is
        incarcerated for several crimes, sentencing court’s lack of jurisdiction to
        sentence him on one of the crimes does not warrant release in habeas
        corpus.
    (No. 96-1933—Submitted January 7, 1997—Decided February 19, 1997.)
     APPEAL from the Court of Appeals for Pickaway County, No. 96 CA 21.
                                ____________________
        {¶ 1} In 1993, the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas convicted
appellant, Joseph Marshall, Jr., of two counts of drug trafficking with
accompanying specifications. The common pleas court sentenced Marshall to
concurrent terms that were to be served consecutively to his sentence in case No.
CR287104.
        {¶ 2} In 1996, Marshall filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the
Court of Appeals for Pickaway County, alleging that he was being illegally
restrained of his liberty by appellee, Alan J. Lazaroff, Warden of the Orient
Correctional Institution. Marshall claimed that he was entitled to immediate release
from prison because the prosecuting attorney’s office perpetrated a fraud by
producing an indictment in his drug trafficking case that was not returned by the
Cuyahoga County Grand Jury. The court of appeals granted Lazaroff’s Civ.R.
12(B)(6) motion and dismissed the petition.
                                ____________________
        Joseph Marshall, Jr., pro se.
                              SUPREME COURT OF OHIO




        Betty D. Montgomery, Attorney General, and Stephanie Harris, Assistant
Attorney General, for appellee.
                              ____________________
        Per Curiam.
        {¶ 3} Marshall asserts in his propositions of law that the court of appeals
erred in dismissing his petition and in not holding an evidentiary hearing. But the
court of appeals properly held that habeas corpus is not available to challenge either
the validity or sufficiency of an indictment. State ex rel. Wilcox v. Seidner (1996),
76 Ohio St.3d 412, 415
, 
667 N.E.2d 1220, 1222
; Luna v. Russell (1994), 
70 Ohio St.3d 561, 562
, 
639 N.E.2d 1168, 1169
. Similarly, allegations of fraud on the part
of the prosecution relating to an indictment are not cognizable in habeas corpus.
State ex rel. Justice v. McMackin (1990), 
53 Ohio St.3d 72, 73
, 
558 N.E.2d 1183
-
1184. Marshall could have raised these claims on direct appeal of his criminal
conviction. State ex rel. Simpson v. Lazaroff (1996), 
75 Ohio St.3d 571
, 
664 N.E.2d 937
.
        {¶ 4} Furthermore, Marshall attacks the validity only of his drug trafficking
sentences. He does not challenge the validity of his sentence in Cuyahoga County
Common Pleas Court case No. CR287104, which is referenced in the entry attached
to his petition. Marshall also did not allege that the sentence in that case had expired
at the time he sought extraordinary relief in habeas corpus. Swiger v. Seidner
(1996), 
74 Ohio St.3d 685, 687
, 
660 N.E.2d 1214, 1216
 (“Where a petitioner is
incarcerated for several crimes, the fact that the sentencing court may have lacked
jurisdiction to sentence him on one of the crimes does not warrant his release in
habeas corpus.”).
        {¶ 5} For the foregoing reasons, the court of appeals did not err in granting
Lazaroff’s Civ.R. 12(B)(6) motion to dismiss the petition without holding an
evidentiary hearing. Accordingly, we affirm the judgment of the court of appeals.
                                                                   Judgment affirmed.



                                           2
                            January Term, 1997




      MOYER, C.J., DOUGLAS, RESNICK, F.E. SWEENEY, PFEIFER, COOK and
LUNDBERG STRATTON, JJ., concur.
                         ____________________




                                    3

/1997/ohio/257 · .json · Public domain