Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Ala. App. 545

Mobile Light & Railroad v. George

Alabama Court of Appeals

Decided December 19, 1911

Alabama Court of Appeals · decided 1911-12-19

Heard before Hon. Samuel B. Browne. Action by L. B. George against the Mobile Light & Railroad Company for ,*150.00 damages, for the negligent killing of an.animal. Judgment for plaintiff, and the defendant appeals. The complaint claimed exactly $50.00 in a suit for injury to an animal, and the court was without jurisdiction to hear and determine the cause; hence, the judgment is void. — McClure v. Leigh, 30 Ala. 208; Sec. 3255, Code 1907; Sec. 143, Const. 1901.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1915

2 state decisions

Relies on McClure v. Lay

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Appeal dismissed · Decided 1911-12-19

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

de GRAFFENRIEI), J.

¶1This suit was brought in the circuit court of Mobile County by the appellee against the appellant, and the amount sued for in his complaint was exactly $50. The appellee claimed the above sum of the appellant, because he alleged that an animal of Ms, through the negligence of the servants of the appellant, acting within the scope of their employment, was killed. There was a trial by jury, a verdict for something less than $50, and a judgment on said verdict, and this appeal is taken to reverse said judgment.

¶2Section 143 of the Constitution provides that the circuit court, “in civil cases, other than suits for libel, slander, assaults and battery, and ejectment, shall have no original ¡jurisdiction except where the. matter or sum in controversy exceeds $50.” Section 3255 of the Code provides that the circuit court has authority “to exercise original jurisdiction of all felonies and misdemeanors; of all actions for libel, slander, assault and battery, and of ejectments, without regard to the amount *547involved; and of all other suits and actions at law when the matter or sum in controversy exceeds $50.

¶3As the appellee brought this suit in the circuit court, and as it is not a suit for libel, slander, assault and battery, or ejectment, but is a civil suit, and as the amount claimed in the complaint is exactly $50, it is evident that the circuit court had no original jurisdiction to try the case, and the judgment rendered by it against the appellant is therefore manifestly void.—McLure v. Lay, 30 Ala. 208. We have, therefore, in this case, an appeal from a void judgment, and this court has nothing therefore before it. The appeal is dismissed.

¶4Appeal dismissed.

/2/alaapp/545 · .json · Public domain