Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Blackf. 216

Washburn v. Payne

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided May 5, 1829

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1829-05-05

<p>In an action of debt before a justice of the peace, on a bond in the penalty of 175 do!* lars conditioned for the delivery of property, the plaintiff, in the statement of his demand, claimed 81 dollars and 25 cents: Held¡ that the justice had jurisdiction j the sum actually demanded not exceeding 100 dollars.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1903

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1829-05-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Scott, J.

¶1-On a bond for 175 dollars, with condition for the delivery of certain property, an action was brought before a justice of the peace. The plaintiff below, in stating his cause of action before the justice, claimed 81 dollars and 25 cents, and had judgment to that amount. Defendant appealed to the Circuit Court, and thence to this Court. The statute of 1827 gives jurisdiction to a justice of the peace, where the sum due or demanded shall not exceed 100 dollars. From the phraseology of the statute, we are of opinion that the intention of the general assembly was to regulate the jurisdiction of a justice of the peace, not by the amount named in the bond on which suit might be brought, but by the amount actually claimed or demanded by the plaintiff. The amount claimed in this case, and alleged to be due to the plaintiff, is 81 dollars and 25 cents. This sum is clearly within a justice’s jurisdiction under the statute. For this sum judgment was rendered by the justice, and that judgment was correctly affirmed by the CircuiCourt (1).

Per Curiam.

¶2The judgment is affirmed, with 5 per cent, damages and costs.

¶3 “In all actions of debt or assumpsit, wherein the sum due or demanded shall be over 50 dollars and not exceed 100 dollars, exclusive of interest and costs, justices and Circuit Courts shall have concurrent jurisdiction.” R. C. 1831, p. 297.

/2/blackf/216 · .json · Public domain