Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 E.D. Smith 42

Adams v. Kearney

New York Court of Common Pleas

Decided June 15, 1851

New York Court of Common Pleas · decided 1851-06-15

This was an appeal from an order at special term, setting aside a judgment and execution. The facts are sufficiently given in the opinion.

Decided 1851-06-15

By the Court. Woodruff, J.

¶1We are not able to discover, from the papers, the grounds upon which the order at special term was made. The plaintiff had recovered a judgment in the justice’s court, from which the defendant appealed to this court. Pending the appeal, the defendant met the plaintiff’s son, paid him the amount of the judgment below, took his receipt therefor, without payment of the costs on appeal; and the plaintiff’s counsel having afterwards *43obtained an affirmance of the judgment, with costs, and issued execution for such costs, the defendant applied to the special term, and obtained the order from which the present appeal is taken, setting aside the judgment of affirmance rendered by the general term, with all subsequent proceedings, &c.

¶2Without considering, at present, how far it is proper or competent for a single judge, at special term, to set aside a judgment regularly taken at the general term, we are of opinion that the order appealed from was not warranted by the facts stated in the affidavits.

¶3There was no proof that the plaintiff’s son had any authority to receive the money for his father, or settle the judgment. There was no evidence that the plaintiff had received the money.

¶4It was obvious that the payment was a trick on the part of the debtor to avoid paying the costs of the appeal.

¶5If the defendant supposed that the alleged payment furnished any reason for staying the proceedings in this court on the appeal, he should have appeared and obtained the proper order before judgment of affirmance was entered.

¶6We think the order below was improvidently granted, and it should be reversed, with ten dollars costs.

¶7Order reversed.

/2/edsmith/42 · .json · Public domain