Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

2 Edw. Ch. 623

Cooper v. Norwood

New York Court of Chancery

Decided October 3, 1836

New York Court of Chancery · decided 1836-10-03

The complainants had waived an oath to the answer of the defendant. The latter, however, had sworn to.it; and now applied to dissolve the injunction. 10 J At the same time, the complainants moved that an affidavit, made by one J. M. C., might be annexed to and filed with the bill and have the same effect as if it had béen oríginally filed and annexed thereto.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1876

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1836-10-03

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

The Vice-Chancellor:

¶1As to the application now to-annex an affidavit to the answer:—This practice, of attaching an affidavit, made by a disinterested person, to an injunction bill was introduced by the 37th Rule. It may be done, where the defendant’s oath is waived ; but it is not absolutely required.

¶2In the present case, it was not done when the bill was filed; and it is now, for the first time and after an answer has become perfect, asked to be allowed. The affidavit in support of the present motion is not positive as to the intention to make out and annex an affidavit when the bill was prepared ; and it appears that the solicitor for the complainants was not struck with, what he calls, the omission, until he compared the answer with the bill. If such a motion as the present can be tolerated at all, I think it ought clearly to appear that the intention, to file the affidavit with the bill, existed at the time, and that the omission was purely accidental.

¶3I consider the rule allowing an affidavit to be annexed should be strictly observed. A party has no right to wait until the coming in of the answer and then, upon finding the necessity of the thing, ask for permission. This motion cannot be granted.

¶4Motion denied, with costs; and the injunction was dissolved, in consequence of the answer having denied the equity of the bill.

/2/edwch/623 · .json · Public domain